Wednesday, June 13, 2018

O Little Town of Bethlehem

This is where Jesus was born!
Tonight I will be going to sleep happy, full, and hopeful because of my experience visiting Bethlehem today. Due to various reasons related to insurance and liability, my study abroad program is not allowed to bring us into the Palestinian territories. (Although, we are allowed to travel to settlements, which are considered Israeli land by the state of Israel, the United States, and our insurance company, and are considered a violation of international law and officially Palestinian territory by the majority of the world.) However, after we finish our programming each day, we have free time; as we are all adults, we don't have any official rules regarding our mobility during evenings and weekends. Some members of my cohort were eager to visit Palestinian cities like Ramallah, Bethlehem, and Hebron, but I was among those who were more hesitant. Today, however, a group of us finally ventured into the West Bank, both the visit the birthplace of Jesus and to see for ourselves what life in the Palestinian territories might look like.


This is the separation wall
that defines the western
edges of the city. 
There is a lot of tangible and explicit fear within Israeli society regarding their wellbeing in the Palestinian territories. From an objective perspective, this is understandable for multiple reasons: the violent attacks that have been carried out by Palestinians against Israelis; the narrative that is taught in Israeli schools, in which Palestinians are the other and a threat to Israeli prosperity; and the lack of sustained and meaningful contact between Israelis and Palestinians. As my mother will affirm, likely painfully, I have a very low sense of danger. This means that I am very trusting of others, but it also means that I don't think bad things will happen to me, and am often less wary of my surroundings than I should be. I was not concerned for my safety before we went to Bethlehem, largely because I know that, as an American, I am a less appealing target for an attack, fortunately/unfortunately. 


Nevertheless, I went into our excursion with preconceived notions about what Bethlehem would be like. These were based on information from classes I've taken at Tulane, individual research, and the last week and a half in this program. I expected the harsh economic conditions that I've learned about to be more apparent, for people to look at me critically because I am a white American (and therefore stick out like a sore thumb), and to feel less comfortable than I do in Jerusalem. My experience in Bethlehem ended up being the opposite of that. I was amazed by how much cleaner the city looked than Jerusalem, especially East Jerusalem. (Of course, East Jerusalem is also predominantly Palestinian neighborhoods, and as I mentioned in my last post, there are instances of systemic barriers that perpetuate the economic inequality and worsen the living conditions there.) I was only catcalled once, while I have been catcalled multiple times each day that I've been in Jerusalem. I felt completely comfortable walking on the streets, speaking loudly in English, and holding my phone in my hand.
Across the square from the Church of
the Nativity there is a mosque. I've
noticed in multiple cities that there
are often multiple holy sites right
next to each other. 

These observations were all made within 10 minutes of arriving in the city, and I could have returned to Jerusalem in that moment with a sweet taste in my mouth. However, my friends and I ended up spending about three hours there total because of the connection we formed with our taxi driver. To get to Bethlehem from Jerusalem, you can take a bus from the Old City to a checkpoint in the separation wall. After you walk through the checkpoint, you can walk or take a taxi into the city center. We found a man that was willing to drive all 6 of us in one car and we set off. My friend Elli spent the first semester of this year in Jordan, so her Arabic is great; luckily, she was sitting in the front seat and quickly hit it off with the driver, Ashraf. Another girl, Grace, and I chimed into the conversation occasionally, but I don't think we would have gotten along so well without Elli. 


This is one of many graffiti
works on the separation wall.
It was interesting to compare
this piece with the numerous
signs in Jerusalem that
celebrate President Trump.
Ashraf offered to drive us to various places in the city before taking us back to the checkpoint for a fixed price of 120 shekels total (that's less than $34), but between stops extended his generosity even further and invited us to his home to break fast (for Ramadan) with his family. After a few quick looks around the car, we eagerly accepted his offer. After visiting the Church of the Nativity and driving around Bethlehem, we went to Ashraf's house. He explained to us as we drove up a street that all of his family lived in that area-- it was essentially a neighborhood filled with only one family. After admiring the beautiful view of the city from his street, we went inside. He was very hospitable and insisted on having us all sit on the couch while he brought out coffee. None of us touched it, so he brought us into the kitchen to meet his wife, who was preparing the food, and daughters, who were probably playing around and chatting before we arrived. All of the women were very welcoming and hospitable, but I also got the sense that they were either shocked or amused (or both) that 6 random Americans were in their home.


Elli and I tried to talk with the kids, especially Ashraf's 5-year-old daughter, Rahma, but she was shy at first, and our conversation mostly consisted of broken sentences on our part and timid smiles on her part. She was really cute. After about 10 minutes, the food was ready and Ashraf insisted on us helping ourselves first. We were hesitant, because they had been fasting all day and were likely hungrier than we were, but we quickly realized that delaying our own eating would just delay theirs even more, so we dug in. It was a delicious meal of rice, chicken, and a bunch of other things that I have never seen before. I don't know if I'll ever stop being shocked at how good Middle Eastern food is-- the various spices and flavors make it so much more exciting than any other cuisine I've tried. 
Elli, Izzy, and me in Ashraf's living room
eating delicious deserts made specially
for Ramadan.

After eating a lot of food by our standards and not enough by Ashraf's and his family's standards, we moved back into the living room for coffee, dessert, and cigarettes (for the men). Two of the daughters showed off their dresses for Eid al-Fitr (the celebration for the end of Ramadan, which is this Friday) and an upcoming family wedding (which we got invited to, but is after we return to the United States, unfortunately), and we fumbled our way through Arabic conversation as various family members came and went. We even Facetimed Ashraf's brother-in-law who lives in Michigan, which was perhaps the only bizarre moment of the night, as the rest of the time I felt very welcome and comfortable. Eventually we gathered ourselves, made the rounds to express our gratitude and say goodbye, and headed back to the checkpoint. We ended up paying Ashraf more than he had originally asked for, but it still felt insufficient because of his immense generosity. He also insisted on adding us all on Facebook so that if we ever come back to Bethlehem, we can visit him and his family. 

Leila Khaled is a controversial
individual because of her role
in the PFLP (considered a
terrorist organization by many)
and her status as a female
Palestinian freedom fighter. 
Once we left Ashraf's car, it felt a bit like a bubble had burst around us. When we went through the checkpoint on our way to Bethlehem, we had walked through three revolving gates, and that was it. I was expecting the way back into Israel to be a bit more complex than that, but I was unprepared for how it really was. To enter, walked up a long corridor that has no lights, and therefore was pitch black. It felt like I was a cow being led through a corridor in a barn. After that, we went through a revolving gate, walk across a lot, go through another revolving gate, and walk down another cattle-esque corridor. Eventually we reached a room that has a metal detector and security belt, like at the airport. Finally, we walked down another hallway until we reached a couple machines and a manned booth. The machines let Palestinians through who have special permit cards that scan, while those who don't have the cards must wait in the single line that leads to the manned booth; they must obtain approval from the guard there to pass through. There were also two guards on the opposite side, both armed with machine guns, who saw us tourists and waved us over. They took one look at my American passport and let all 6 of us through without any issue. We went through one last revolving gate and finally made it out to the bus stop, where we caught a bus back to the Old City. 

When we headed out for Bethlehem in the late afternoon, I had the Palestinian-Israeli conflict on my mind, in part because we had just gotten back from a long day of lectures and a visit to a controversial settlement, and in part because I'm struggling to think about anything else these days. It was still present during our time in Bethlehem, especially when we visited an area of the separation wall that is covered in graffiti. At the same time, the whole time that we were with Ashraf and his family, we never mentioned politics or the conflict. We said the words "Israel" and "Palestine," spoke about Ashraf's former employment in Israel, and mentioned the intifada, but Ashraf did not seem inclined to talk about it beyond that. Instead, he spoke about the upcoming festivities of Eid and the wedding, his desire for his daughter to be a doctor, his pride in his niece who is a dentist, and his goal of putting food on the table and providing for his family. 

Another work from the separation wall. It says
"But please don't forget to find the human in
your enemy"
I think it's important for me to acknowledge that Bethlehem also receives thousands of Christian tourists each day, and therefore is one of the wealthiest parts of the West Bank. I am sure that if I went to another city or to a small village, my experience would be very different. However, I feel much more confident that both my ability to navigate a new place is sufficient and that others would treat me well. One of my goals in participating in this program is to collect as many perspectives and experiences from people who are related to and impacted by the conflict. Today I learned that one average Palestinian family does not spend all their time thinking about Israeli-Palestinian relations. I learned that this one family does not see outsiders or The Other as a threat, but rather as someone to welcome into their home. I learned the importance of stepping outside of your comfort zone while extending an open hand, an olive branch, or whatever other peaceful symbol you want to use, to others around you. 

1 comment:

  1. Bel, how fortunate that you and your fellow travelers were received so generously by Ashraf and his family! I'm glad that you were willing to step outside your comfort zone, and that you were quick to put your Arabic to use. Is it your sense that expectations of hospitality are heightened during Ramadan, or is this simply part of what some Palestinians may do to make their own world less confining? Thanks for including the photos and captions in your posts -- very helpful for those of us who haven't been there to see and read about your discoveries in vivid detail!

    ReplyDelete