This blog post is long overdue; I meant to write it before I left Israel, but that was almost a week ago, and here I am sitting in a coffee shop in New Orleans. I probably wouldn't be here if my friend, Julia, hadn't motivated me with her offer of an air-conditioned ride and unobtrusive company. Part of the reason that this last post has been so difficult to write is that I still have so many thoughts about this conflict bouncing around in my mind and it's hard to focus in on them when I have distractions like mattress deliveries, grocery shopping, and friends' housewarming parties calling my name. It's somewhat unnerving how easily I have settled back into my life in New Orleans; although I was only in Israel/Palestine for three weeks, the conversations I was having and the activities I was engaging in were widely different from my everyday life, and I expected to need more time to transition back.
The idea that is shining the strongest in my head right now is the role of education, and I mentioned in my last post that I would address it, so here we are. One of the last speakers that we met with during the program was an Arab Christian woman, Elli, who grew up in a Palestinian neighborhood in Israel. Elli attended an Israeli school with a predominantly Israeli-Jewish student body, but also had friends from her neighborhood who were Palestinian, so she grew up in the middle of both worlds. Two years ago, she launched a pilot program called Peace Heroes that consists of a values-based curriculum that is to be implemented over four years in elementary schools. She created the curriculum because she wanted to give children living in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict the vocabulary and ideas to address the conflict and work through the difficulties they face everyday. Peace Heroes teaches students about 60 peace heroes from all different nationalities, genders, ethnicities, religions, and other backgrounds, and encourages them to cultivate values like hospitality, diversity, and nonviolence. It has been implemented in two Israeli schools, two Palestinian schools, and six other schools in Burundi, South Africa, Kenya, and Iraqi refugee camps.
A small part of me was dubious when Elli started talking because it seemed almost too good to be true. She claimed that there had been hardly any backlash from the parents, but the program is still new and it seems like there would be a lot of obstacles. At the same time, I was excited to hear about an effort to prepare the next generation to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through nonviolent measures. This conflict has been going on for over 100 years, since before the creation of the state of Israel, and it seems like a solution is impossible when babies are born into it and children learn (usually unintentionally, in school, at home, through the media, etc.) to distrust, target, or even hate the other. Peace Heroes is not the first effort to solve or improve the conflict through education that we encountered that; we spoke with multiple people about bilingual schools, interfaith school groups, and other attempts to teach peace.
I've started to wonder recently if education is really just another form of brainwashing. That word seems so dirty and ominous, but school is such a powerful institution and the teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults have so much influence over how the students develop. When these adults want to teach the kids to respect their peers, to appreciate different backgrounds, to honor their commitments, and to be patient with themselves, we applaud them for their commitment to bettering youth. However, if these adults were to instead teach the kids to put their own desires before those of others, to only play with kids who looked like them, or to punch a wall when they're mad, we would condemn them for creating little monsters.
Regardless of what we call it, I think it is better to teach kids the first set of values I mentioned, but why should I get to comment on that? Where do teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults get the authority from the decide what values kids are being taught? I would like to see a new generation of Israelis and Palestinians raised to solve the conflict through nonviolent means, but I worry that this questions of authority and decision making regarding education will be too big of an obstacle to spreading curricula like Peace Heroes to more schools.
No comments:
Post a Comment