It seems as though I should be accustomed to the obstacles to mobility that the Israeli government imposes in the name of security, but I was still appalled and frustrated by our experiences crossing the border, both into Jordan and back into Israel. (When we crossed into Jordan, the Jordanian government was also very extra, as the kids say these days.) On the way to Jordan, we took a bus from the dorms in Jerusalem to the departure gate at the border. As we stepped off the bus, an employee told us to deposit our bags onto two luggage carts, and that we would pick them up after we had gone through the agents inside. Once inside, we waited for about an hour while one professor and one student spoke with the border control agents. Finally, the professor coughed up $40 per participant for the exit fee (he'll be reimbursed at some point) and we were allowed to exit onto the other side of the building, where our bags were waiting for us. Another agent told us to put the bags in the bottom of a bus and get on board.
![]() |
| This picture is not at all related to the content of this post, but it was taken at the ruins of the Temple of Hercules in Amman. |
We rode, excruciatingly slowly, along a road for about a mile until we were stopped again. A Jordanian border control agent boarded and collected all of our passports and gave them to the driver. Then we continued for about another mile, until we reached the Jordanian arrivals hall. Upon arrival, another man boarded the bus and asked for payment for every bag that had been put under the bus, despite the fact that no one ever said it cost money to store our bags there. We went through a metal detector and bag inspection point, then waited to collect our passports again. Once we had finally gotten all 17 passports, we piled into a van provided by CIEE (the study abroad company hosting us in Jordan) and drove to Amman. Although the distance between Jerusalem and Amman is only 45 miles, it took us 4 hours to get through the whole chaotic mess.
When we returned to Israel, it took less time overall to get from the CIEE center in Amman to our dorms in Jerusalem, but it was a more frustrating process because of the behavior of the Israeli border control agents. Two students and one administrator were asked to step aside and await further questions; none of them were white. The same thing happened when we arrived in Israel from the United States, and the students had to wait in the airport for multiple hours before they were questioned and processed, so we expected to wait for awhile in the arrivals hall. In the end, they were only detained for about 30 minutes and weren't asked any extra questions, but it was frustrating to witness, because of the blatant racism, and surely even more upsetting to actually experience. Part of what made it so infuriating is that multiple participants in the program have made inflammatory comments against Israel, and one is even on the leadership of Students for Justice in Palestine, which is an organization that supports the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel. However, that student is also Jewish and white, so there was no issue with crossing the border.
| Again, this is an unrelated picture of the group at the Roman amphitheater in Amman as we try to look silly. |
While I was in the bathroom, I started to feel bad about myself. I felt like everybody else in the program was handling the material without an issue, and I chided myself for not having a thicker skin. It was only the next day, after talking to the Palestinian refugees, that I was able to forgive myself for getting upset during the lecture. When we met with the refugees, we immediately launched into a Q&A session. It was the first chance that we had to talk with people who had left Israel/Palestine, and we were all eager to hear about this new perspective. Given the nature of the program, and the personalities of the people in our group, most of our questions related to the hardships they faced as refugees, the unequal treatment they experienced in Jordanian society, and the injustice that had been inflicted on them when they were expelled from their homes.
| Here's one more irrelevant picture. It is a compilation of pictures taken during a scavenger hunt around a neighborhood in Amman. We made it into a peace sign because we are in a peace cult. |
There were four women of all ages and one young man, but the conversation was mostly dominated by the two middle-aged women who seemed to be the most eager to engage with us. They answered our questions with stories about their experiences and those of their friends and family, and they largely confirmed a lot of what I have read in textbooks and other academic texts about the plights of Palestinian refugees. I was caught off guard when one of the women eventually diverged from the questions we'd been asking and reminded us that we were the ones who came in and started asking about their struggles. She shared that even though their lives were impacted every day by the conflict and even though they did face a lot of hardship, they also were concerned with other things besides the topics we'd been discussing. She spoke of the joy of getting her children engaged, the pride of having her daughter graduate college, and the way that they maintained their Palestinian culture during every celebration, through food, music, and clothing.
Her comment felt like a reminder that part of humanizing the actors in this conflict means letting them experience the ups and downs of daily life in the same way that I do. There are big differences that are important to acknowledge, but it would also be unfair to simplify the life of a Palestinian refugee to just pain and suffering. Life sucks a lot, and there are a lot of really bad things happening all the time, but sometimes it's okay to focus on the good things, even if they are small.

No comments:
Post a Comment