Thursday, April 18, 2019

My Experience as an American Feminist in Jordan, Pt. 2 - Reflecting 7 Months Later

Before I went to Brazil for my gap year, my mom suggested that I keep a diary in Portuguese so that I could both reminisce on the details of my highs and lows and evaluate how much my language had improved over time. Although the entries are few, I still love reading back through the diary and being reminded of little things I had forgotten, including how bad my Portuguese used to be! I have tried to keep a diary this year, too, but, similarly to my experience in Brazil, I have not been very committed to writing in it regularly. Recently, when I was feeling down about my lack of obvious language improvement this semester, I searched for my first entry in the hopes that it would lift my spirits. Unfortunately, I switched diaries over winter break and left the first one in the U.S., so I will have to wait until I return to read that.



Interning at the National Association
for Family Empowerment (NAFE)
 this semester has taught me a lot
about challenges that Jordanian
women face in practicing their
economic and social rights. It is
also interesting because the office
has more female employees than
male ones!
As I was in the mood to look back at my experiences in Jordan, I decided to read some of my previous blog posts, including the one I wrote about being an American feminist in Jordan. I have to admit, I giggled a bit at some of the concerns that I had a few months ago, such as the need to dry my hair before going outside. I had never asked a Jordanian if it would be bad for me to leave the house with wet hair, but I also never saw any evidence of women doing this, so I believed the blogs and Trip Advisor comments. One day early this semester, I woke up later than I had planned, but really needed to shower. I turned to my Jordanian roommate and asked her if it was haram for me to go to school with wet hair. She stared at me for a moment, then told me it would be fine as long as I wore a coat with a hood. I asked if she meant that I should cover my hair with a scarf, similar to a hijab, which made her laugh. Eventually she explained that, socially, there was no problem for me to go outside with wet hair, but that I should cover my head to avoid getting sick. Later that day, I asked a few other Jordanian women about this, and they all agreed that wet hair was only a concern if it was cold outside. It is possible, of course, that there are Jordanians who would disagree and insist that I only leave the house with wet hair. However, since then, I have gone outside shortly after showering countless times. No one has said anything or given me a strange look, and I have begun to wonder if the blow dryers in the gyms aren't actually for hijabi women to dry their hair after they shower so that their scarves don't get wet.

My gym membership has also changed from last semester to this semester, and rather than the women's gym, now I go to a co-ed one. There are many more male patrons than female ones, but it feels pretty similar to the weight room in any American gym. The gym only has one bathroom, but the owner is dedicated to making the women feel comfortable and welcome, and he will kick out the men if a woman wants to use it. There are, of course, guys who stare at me and the other women as we work out. Sometimes they will start a conversation, but I think that they are more interested in my nationality than my gender, and when I have asked them to leave me in peace, they oblige. This has generally been the attitude that I have encountered with men in other spaces in Jordan. Any time that I take a taxi or Uber by myself, I can expect to have a conversation with the driver; half the time, these conversations include a proposal of marriage to, or at least casual mention of, one of his single sons. There have been a couple of times that I felt uncomfortable just saying no, so I invented an American boyfriend waiting for me in the U.S., but I usually just laugh, thank him for the offer, and deny it. In general, I feel very comfortable taking taxis and Ubers by myself, and I think that is thanks to both my language improvement and my observation of local women as they navigate similar situations with confidence and poise.

The teaching staff at CET is almost
entirely Jordanian women, and they
served as wonderful role models for me
and the other students in the program!
I touched on this briefly in my first post on this topic, but I think the most important factor to consider when I talk about my experience as a woman in Jordan is my nationality. Hospitality and origin/descent are really important concepts in Jordanian society, and ones that lead to preferential treatment for me. As a guest in this country, Jordanians go to great lengths to welcome me and make me feel comfortable, whether that means inviting me to their homes, offering me tea and coffee, or shaming a street harasser for disrespecting a guest. Furthermore, my nationality and subsequent lack of family in Jordan changes how potential perpetrators view me. A well-known family name can be a double-edged sword in Jordan. On the one hand, knowing that a girl is from a big family that will seek revenge for any crime committed against her deters some perpetrators, but on the other hand, the notion that a female reflects her family's honor leads to familial violence against women who are suspected to have tainted that honor. While the American Embassy does not have the same fear factor as a powerful, Jordanian family, it does offer some deterrence, and I have yet to hear of them committing honor crimes.

At the same time, as an American, I stand out both physically and linguistically, which may draw extra attention. Sometimes, this means a group of boys shout a few simple words at me in English (i.e. "Hello, hello!" or "Welcome to Egpyt!" The second phrase really confuses me, but I've heard it about three times, in Jordan...), and sometimes it means people want to show me off to their friends and family because it ups their cool factor. The street harassment, which includes both verbal harassment, staring, and honking from anything on wheels, is not enjoyable, but I have found that I have grown accustomed to it. More importantly than that, I know that the harassment will stop there.


My Jordanian roommate, who has
not 
only guided me in navigating
 societal 
expectations of women's 
behavior, but also engaged in many, 
many discussions comparing
Jordanian and 
American culture. 
I think part of the reason that I was so put off at the beginning of last semester is because I was trying to fit my experience in Jordan into the mindset that has been developed from my life in the U.S. In spring 2017, Tulane conducted a climate survey that found that 41% of female students and 18% of male students had survived sexual assault since enrolling at Tulane. Given these statistics, it is not surprising that most of the young women and many of the young men I know have faced sexual assault in college or high school. Most studies find that the majority of perpetrators were previously-known by the survivors, but books and movies, such as "The Lovely Bones" and "Room," as well as my own friends' and classmates' experiences, have made me fearful that anyone who harasses me on the street could just as easily attack me. I know that when I return to the U.S., I will still have this fear living inside me and influencing the where, when, and how of my mobility. However, after seven months in Jordan, I can confirm that I don't have that same fear here. I don't doubt that there are a handful of bad apples here, but I also think that the police and the courts take allegations of sexual harassment and assault more seriously here than in the U.S., where we have yet to establish a culture of believing survivors.

Undoubtedly, there are many women who are discouraged from reporting sexual assault because of the aforementioned threat to their own well-being. In addition to that, there are further complications that survivors face in both reporting and seeking medical attention when they come from a lower-income community or hold refugee status, rather than Jordanian nationality. I could write a few more pages about that topic, but I have already taken way too much time away from my homework by writing this, so I will wrap it up now. The main point that I wanted to make in this post is that my understanding of what it means to be a woman in Jordan has changed over the past few months. The last time I wrote about being an American feminist in Jordan, I was concerned with how, on the surface level, I faced different forms of discrimination than what I was used to in my home community. Now, I have decided that, on the surface, Jordan and the U.S. offer women respect and equality in really different ways, and sometimes it feels impossible to compare the two. However, when you look deeper than street harassment and income inequality, both countries are guilty of perpetuating really problematic systems that position women as second-class citizens, and only get worse when race, nationality, and other aspects of their identities are factored in.

Saturday, March 16, 2019

Is it better for us to fly over Syria or Israel?

About a month ago, my friends and I were in a taxi discussing our spring break plans. We wanted to go to Lebanon, and we somehow got on the topic of the flight path from Amman to Beirut. As the conversation was in Arabic, our taxi driver chimed in to remind us that the plane couldn't fly over Syria because of the war. We all glanced at each other, and I saw looks of wonder that I am sure reflected my own facial expression. It had never occurred to us that we wouldn't be able to fly over Syria. I wondered for a moment if we would see evidence of the war if we did fly over it. Would a rocket shoot past the window? Could we look down and see ISIS fighters?

The view of Syria
from the plane!
We did end up booking flights to Lebanon, and I forgot all about the flight path question until we were on the plane and my friend leaned across the aisle to inform us that we had just flown over Damascus. I was sitting in the window seat, but I had been ignoring the view as I tried to get some homework done before we arrived and really started our break. I was shocked when she said that, and immediately abandoned my assignment to gaze out the window. Instead of rockets and ISIS fighters, I saw villages nestled between mountains whose tops were dusted with snow; the scene was beautiful and peaceful. Of course, there probably was some fighting going on that couldn't be seen from that high up, but it felt surreal to look at Syria and not see any evidence of the war that has caused so many people to flee their homes. My friends and I were interested by the fact that the Lebanese airline preferred to fly through Syrian airspace, rather than flying through Israeli airspace. The flight was only 40 minutes, but in that time, I think I saw more evidence of geopolitics than I've ever seen in my daily life in Jordan.

The view in the north of Lebanon.
One of the friends I traveled with is of Lebanese descent, so her extended family picked us up from the airport and helped us find our AirBnB. The next day, they took us to a couple of towns in the north of Lebanon, where they have a winter home outside of Tripoli and a summer home in the mountains. Lebanese society is somewhat divided based on religious lines, and as they are Christian, the tour they gave us included multiple churches and predominantly Christian areas of the country. They were kind and generous, and showed us parts of the country that we likely would not have even known to visit without them, but we struggled to communicate much more than I had expected.

Just a random picture of me with a
nice view of the Mediterranean Sea :)
After studying in Jordan for almost 6 months, I have become very comfortable in my Arabic skills, and I can almost always communicate with people in Jordan. I assumed that I would have a similar experience in Lebanon because the countries of the Levant are considered to have similar dialects of Arabic. However, there is significant French influence in Lebanon that started when Lebanon was a French mandate after World War II, and we encountered more people who spoke French than people who spoke English. As such, during our tour with my friend's family, their sixteen year old daughter had to translate most of the conversations; I was very impressed with her ability to juggle Lebanese Arabic, Jordanian Arabic, English, and French all at the same time. They were very patient with us, but they did laugh when we said the Arabic word for "Thank you," which is "Shukran," instead of saying "Merci." This elicited some frustrated eye rolls and giggles from our group, but we made sure to say "Merci" for the rest of the week.

The rest of the week mostly consisted of typical tourist activities around Beirut and northern Lebanon. We saw stalactites, stalagmites, and a deep abyss that looked like the entrance to Hell in Jeita Grotto, rode a gondola lift up to a giant statue of the Virgin Mary, walked through an outdoor market housed in a former Crusader castle in Byblos, took a boat tour through caves along the coast in Beirut, went to the beach (twice!), and ate lots of good food. The trip ended up being pretty different than my expectations; after studying the politics of Lebanon somewhat extensively, I thought that I would learn more about the sectarian divides in Lebanese society and see more evidence of the wars that have taken place in the country. Now that I am reflecting on the week, I am kind of glad that we stuck to pretty light, touristy activities, because my mind needed a break.

Me preparing to dress
conservatively for the
Hizballah Museum. I
did not actually cover
my hair... haha
However, we did have one day where we diverged from the beaches and traditional tourist spots. On our last full day in Lebanon, we ventured to the Tourist Landmark of the Resistance, which is a museum and war memorial that is operated by Hizballah. I was a bit apprehensive to go because the museum is located in southern Lebanon, which almost every European government considers one of the more dangerous parts of the country, because it is controlled by Hizballah. I think that my friends were also nervous about going, but no one said anything until we were heading back to Beirut after the museum visit, and my friend asked us if we thought the taxi driver would keep driving if Israel started bombing the area. The same thought had just gone through my mind, and I told them that we shouldn't tell our parents right away, in case we were rescued that same day, but that we should contact the AirBnB owner before our phones died so that he didn't throw away our stuff. This prompted lots of laughter as they teased me for prioritizing contacting the AirBnB owner over contacting the US Embassy.


As for the visit, it was probably one of the most interesting experiences of my life. I wish I had another adjective to use, but I think that interesting best captures the full range of feelings I had while we were there, which included fascination, confusion, and extreme discomfort. The tour is meant to start with a video from the group's Secretary-General, but we arrived there shortly after a group from Britain, and the English-speaking tour guide (who was a member of Hizballah and wore a Prada hat) suggested that we join their group and watch the video at the end. We started at the Abyss, which is a shallow pit filled with Israeli tanks, bullets, barbed wire, and other artifacts from the wars between Israel and Lebanon. My confusion started during this part as our guide gave us his take on the conflict between Israel and Lebanon. It was hard to follow the history lesson he provided to back up his claim to the Lebanese land, and it caught me off guard because I usually only hear disputes over the land in Israel/Palestine.

The Abyss at the Hizballah museum.
As we were walking to the next part of the tour, which was a series of bunkers and tunnels in the hillside that were used during fights with Israel, the guide asked the British people in the group why their prime minister had recently added Hizballah to the terrorist watch list. They sputtered out a pretty bad response (something along the lines of "Oh, I'm sure there was a reason behind that") while we all stifled out laughter and pretended to be coughing and sneezing. I was glad that he asked them first, because it gave me a chance to brainstorm a better answer for when he inevitably asked us the same question. Luckily, he only asked us if we knew which state in the US recently added the group to the state's list. I sarcastically offered up Texas, but it is actually Connecticut.

After wandering through the tunnels, we reached probably the most uncomfortable part of the whole day, which was the indoor part of the museum. It was meant to demonstrate the Lebanese resistance against Israeli occupation and terror, but what I saw was more along the lines of gloating about defeating the Israeli army. The museum was just one room, and it was full of Israeli artifacts that had been collected after the fighting, including ID cards and notebooks from IDF soldiers. I am pretty open about my disagreement with policy decisions from the Israeli government, but I felt extremely uncomfortable seeing the spoils of war being proudly displayed like that because the soldiers who were killed were likely Israeli youth who are forced by their government to serve in the military. We ended the visit with the video from the Secretary-General, which was so blatantly propaganda that I couldn't help but laugh. Overall, I am glad that we visited, but I don't think I would like to return to that museum in the future.

Lebanon is a beautiful country!!!
Before I left for Lebanon, I posted on a Facebook group called Girls Love Travel and asked if anyone had recommendations of things to do in Lebanon. Aside from my friends, the only person who commented was a woman who was warning me that I should reconsider travel to Lebanon because the State Department has a Level 3 warning. I responded with a somewhat sassy comment that thanked her for her concern, and promised that I would avoid the Syrian border. Maybe I got lucky with the timing, but I did not feel unsafe the entire time I was in Lebanon. Everyone was so welcoming, and got excited when we tried to speak with them in Arabic. This trip was a reminder of how important it is to seek opportunities to learn about countries and cultures through my own experiences. So, if any of you are planning a trip to Lebanon, you should definitely do it!

Friday, February 15, 2019

Coming Back From My Blogging Hiatus

Last semester, I often had ideas for blog posts but couldn't find the time to write them, especially at the end of the semester. Now that I am back in Jordan for another semester, I am finding that I have the opposite problem: I keep thinking, "I should really post something on my blog..." but when I try to decide what to write about, I come up short. I think part of the issue is that the novelty has worn off and my being in Jordan doesn't feel as much like a blog-worthy adventure as it did a few months ago. On the other hand, I think that the observations and stories that I would share on my blog have changed in nature.

This semester, I don't find myself watching people interact and wondering "Why do they do that?" nor do I find myself struggling to understand people and get myself where I need to go. I remember the first time I rode a bus last semester and how nervous I was before, during, and even after the ride. That was a pretty normal reaction considering how confusing the bus system is in Amman; there is no published schedules or routes, most busses are just white vans with no helpful markings about where they are going, and often there is a man leaning out the door and shouting the key landmarks that will be passed. However, it wasn't just the bus system that made me nervous about riding the bus. Although I never felt unsafe in Amman last semester, I was always so self-conscious about how I appeared to people on the street. Most of the time they can tell that I am not Jordanian just by glancing at me, but there have been a few times that people asked if I was a local. Of course, that was before I opened my mouth to speak and cleared up any doubts about my nationality. I didn't want to stand out any more than was necessary, so when I rode the bus by myself, I tried to avoid speaking at all costs.

Yesterday, I rode the bus by myself for the first time this semester and it felt like a very different experience. I was going to meet my language partner at a mall that I had always taken a cab to, but she said there was a bus that went there from the University of Jordan (near my apartment). I walked over the main hub for busses and asked one of the guys trying to recruit passengers on to his bus if he would go to that mall. He said his bus would pass near there, and then I could ride a shared taxi the rest of the way. I made a face and said I wanted just one bus, to which he laughed in a friendly way and directed me to another bus. A similar interaction happened with the next bus recruiter, before he suggested a third bus. The third bus was the right one, and after a quick conversation about the route in front of the rest of the passengers, I sat down in my seat.

This entire experience lasted about 7 minutes and would not have been memorable except for the fact that throughout it, no one stared at me funny, no one looked exasperated when I couldn't understand their simple questions, and no one switched to English because they assumed it would be easier for me. I also felt confident in my ability to understand and communicate with any random person on the street or bus, and I know that is a big change since last semester. I still get anxious before I have to speak in formal Arabic (fusHa) because I never really do that, but I have noticed that since I came back to Amman, I feel almost no hesitation speaking in Jordanian Arabic. I am sure there are still many mistakes with my grammar and pronunciation, but I feel much more comfortable and relaxed, and many teachers, TAs, and Jordanian friends from last semester have noticed this change. Of course their comments just add to my new confidence!

The moments of confidence, like my bus ride, have been happening more frequently since I came back to Jordan, but that doesn't mean I haven't also had moments where I feel like I don't know any Arabic at all. Sometimes those happen in the classroom, and other times they happen at my internship. CET has two program tracks in Jordan: the intensive language and the internship. Last semester, I did the intensive language program, which essentially consists of many, many hours of language class every day of the week. This semester, I am doing the internship program. It also includes hours of language class, and can be tweaked to include even more, but classes are only 3 days a week so that students can intern with local organizations for the other 2 days of the week.

I am interning with the National Association for Family Empowerment (click here to see the NAFE website that the other intern and I recently made for them!) which is a local NGO that works to improve Jordanian society by empowering women and youth to make change in their local communities. As you will see if you clicked the link, the website is not finished yet. One reason for that is that we are trying to write everything in Arabic and in English, and while the English part comes very easily, the Arabic part takes a bit longer. I am grateful for my classes last semester that really developed my professional vocabulary in Arabic, but I realized that I don't know a lot of words and etiquette related to online communication. This has led to me making a few mistakes on the website and the Instagram (follow us @nafe.jordan!!) that were likely amusing to the Jordanians, but left me feeling a bit down about the level of my intelligence. Fortunately, all the other employees are very nice and patient, and they're eager to help us with our Arabic and practice their English.

Although I have been involved with NGOs in the past, interning with NAFE is my first chance to see what working at an NGO would look like. Working with any NGO is, of course, a unique experience because of the mission, the style of work, and the people who work there, but it has already been a great opportunity for learning about what kind of career I might want to pursue. What I like about NAFE, and I think this probably applies to many NGOs, is that there is a goal in mind and there are core values that the organization incorporates into its work, but they do it in a realistic way. I'm sure that most of the employees would like to see the elimination of gender-based violence and socioeconomic inequality throughout all of Jordan, and probably the rest of the world, but right now they're focusing their attention on certain communities in a select area of Jordan. I think that I have a lot to learn from this, as I often focus on the big picture and then run into a wall when it is too big for me to take on all at once. I think that interning with NAFE is going to be a really great learning experience for me in many ways, and I am hopeful that I can return the favor by helping them achieve their goals. I am also hopeful that this will be an opportunity for me to see a different side of Jordanian society that I didn't have access to last semester, and I'll try to remember to share any blog-worthy revelations here!