Monday, June 4, 2018

First Day Observations: The Complicated Role of Religion

Today was my first full day in Jerusalem, and it was very enjoyable and insightful, but before I dive into those details, I want to make a note regarding vocabulary. During my time here, I will refer to the area that I am in as Israel/Palestine. I will be including both names because I want to respect both groups that have a claim to the land, and seeing as how none of my ancestors ever lived here, I don't think it's my right to decide which claim is more legitimate. However, I will be writing Israel first because it is the more widely recognized political entity. If this offends you, I am sorry, and please feel free to stop reading here.
This photo is unrelated to this post, but this
is Jesus's tomb, located in the Church of the
Holy Sepulcher. 

Now that I've clarified that, I want to share a bit about what I did today, as well as a couple of observations I made throughout the day. All of the participants met this morning at 8:45 AM and walked over to the Truman Institute, where we will be meeting with most of our lecturers and guest speakers over the next few weeks. There was a welcome breakfast and some opening remarks from the Truman staff who have arranged most of the program. After that, we had two lectures from professors of Hebrew University. The first lecture was a brief overview of  Israel's relationship to the rest of the Middle East and other geopolitical topics, while the second professor addressed the three W's-- What Went Wrong-- regarding the Oslo peace process of the 1990s. The lectures were followed by a quick lunch, then a tour of Jerusalem's Old City. While the tour mostly focused on the Christian and Jewish Quarters, I thought the tour guide did a good job of explaining the complex dynamic that exists between the different groups of the Old City, resulting from competing claims to holy sites and narratives about history. By the time our tour guide told us we were heading to dinner, everyone was pretty excited about the opportunity to sit down and rest for a bit. A group of us walked around the city a bit more after dinner, but when we got home around 8:30 PM, I immediately got ready for bed and am looking forward to sleeping.

Before I go to sleep, though, I want to share two moments that stood out to me today, both of which happened during the tour of the Old City. The first was about halfway through when we climbed up to a lookout point that showed the Western Wall and the Dome of the Rock above al-Aqsa Mosque. As we were walking up to the lookout, I saw a square, brick house with a solar panel, a clothesline full of laundry, and what looked like a couple of water tanks on the roof and terrace. Behind the building stood the golden Dome of the Rock, which was shining in the bright sun. My first thought was that the house looked just like the buildings that you see in favelas in Brazil. It was so startling to me because one part of the scene before me included an image that is so familiar to me, and one that symbolizes poverty and inequality for me, while the other part held one of the holiest and most contested sites in the world.
It was pretty hard to capture it in a picture, but the house I mention
is to the left, while the Dome of the Rock is on the right. 

I eventually realized that the tanks were not necessarily filled with water, that solar panels are often expensive, and that the building I was looking at was in much better condition than the dilapidated houses of most of Brazil's favelas. Nevertheless, the juxtaposition of those two images made me start thinking about the fact that millions of people, both Israeli and Palestinian, are suffering economically because of the ongoing conflict. I won't get into the details of how the conflict hinders both the Israeli and the Palestinian economies, but I will say that many Israelis, especially younger ones, struggle to find affordable places to live as they face the growing housing crisis, while almost 15% and over 50% of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, respectively, live in poverty or below the poverty line. Faced with these facts and statistics, I am fascinated by the fact that the economy does have as prominent of a role in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as issues of cultural and religious ties do. Looking at the brick house next to the Dome of the Rock, I was reminded of how harmful this conflict has been to the livelihoods of millions of people. 


Another unrelated photo, but this is where Jesus
was supposedly crucified. 
The second particularly memorable moment from today was when our group visited the Western Wall. Today was actually my second time going, as a few of the other participants and I ventured to the Old City yesterday evening to browse the market stalls in the Muslim Quarter. I've had numerous secular Jewish friends express to me that the moment in their entire lives in which they felt the most connected to Judaism and to God was when they went to the Western Wall. I don't consider myself much of a religious person, but I have found that when I enter a church, especially an old one, I often feel very calm and very spiritual. I was expecting to feel a similar way when I went to the Western Wall, and I was surprised when I felt nothing during our visit last night. However, when we went back today, my experience was notably different. One of the girls on the trip had brought a pack of sticky notes in her purse so that anyone who wanted to could write a note to stick in the wall. I took one, wrote a prayer on it, and went up to the wall to wait my turn.

While I was waiting, I observed the women around me. There were two older white women who had pulled chairs up to the wall and were praying out of books (I am unfamiliar with most Jewish customs, so I don't know what text it was, but it was in Hebrew). They were dressed very conservatively, with their hair covered, and looked like they were not planning to leave their spot anytime soon. Further along the wall, I saw a black woman wearing what looked like a traditional African dress and hair wrap. Next to her, I saw a young girl fidgeting around while her mom, who wore jeans and a button up shirt, finished her prayer. The women's section** was very crowded, and yet it was relatively quiet and extremely peaceful. Once it was my turn to go up to the wall, I felt a familiar feeling of serenity and spirituality rush through me, similarly to what I feel when I enter old churches (i.e. the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, which was a stop on our tour). Although there were clearly women of different races, nationalities, ethnicities, religions, and even interpretations of the same religions, in such a small space, everyone was able to respect one another and share the wall's holy and historic value. Interestingly, when I left the women's section and was walking back to the group, I felt that sense of peace fade extremely quickly. It made me think about all the animosity that exists between the three dominant religions of the world (not just in this particular conflict), and how Christians, Muslims, and Jews are often pitted against one another, but ultimately, we are all praying to the same God. People often fight with one another because of religious beliefs or claims to religious ties, but these same beliefs or practices can also be useful in bringing people from different backgrounds together in a peaceful manner.

You can see the men's side of the Western Wall on the left,
 and the women's side on the right.

Less than 48 hours have passed since I arrived in Israel/Palestine, but I have already been provided with many opportunities and prompts to reflect on and challenge common narratives regarding politics, history, and religion, as well as my own beliefs about the world around me. I'm looking forward to the next few weeks, which will likely both exhaust me and satiate my curiosity. Thanks for reading!

**For those who haven't been, the Western Wall is divided into two sections, one for men and one for women. I believe that each side was of equal length at one point, but over the years, the men's side has been expanded at the expense of the women's. Now, the women have access to 12 of the 60 meters of the wall. Last night, there were many people praying and both sides were fairly crowded, although there was a noticeable difference between the two sides in terms of population density. Today, that difference was even more striking. I would guess that about half of the men's section was empty, while women were squishing together on the other side of the partition, trying to get as many people to be able to pray at once as possible. I saw multiple women pushing their way through the crowd or slipping into an empty spot seemingly out of nowhere. I didn't get a sense of aggressiveness or hostility towards one another, but it was slightly frustrating to contrast how easily men can walk up to the wall with the effort that women must put in to secure a spot for 30 seconds. There is actually a movement called Women of the Wall, which fights against this unequal separation.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Bel, nice blog. Enjoyed reading it and want more. And down with the unequal division for men and women. I could be wrong (it happens sometimes...) but I think the women's section is relatively recent and the product of some controversy. But, not sure.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bel, I loved reading your account of the Western wall and imagining you there, taking your place and having your own moment amidst the variety of people. You are right to note how much room for common ground there is among world religions and among people ready to respect each other's beliefs and perspectives. From what you and others have said, the remarkable closeness and deep investment in the symbolism of places in the Old City also feeds conflicts. What are people saying about the US Embassy? I am grateful that you are there with a program and with people who are committed to looking at the I/P conflict from various sides. Keep writing and sharing your images, observations and discoveries!

    ReplyDelete