Thursday, June 28, 2018

Education in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

This blog post is long overdue; I meant to write it before I left Israel, but that was almost a week ago, and here I am sitting in a coffee shop in New Orleans. I probably wouldn't be here if my friend, Julia, hadn't motivated me with her offer of an air-conditioned ride and unobtrusive company. Part of the reason that this last post has been so difficult to write is that I still have so many thoughts about this conflict bouncing around in my mind and it's hard to focus in on them when I have distractions like mattress deliveries, grocery shopping, and friends' housewarming parties calling my name. It's somewhat unnerving how easily I have settled back into my life in New Orleans; although I was only in Israel/Palestine for three weeks, the conversations I was having and the activities I was engaging in were widely different from my everyday life, and I expected to need more time to transition back.

The idea that is shining the strongest in my head right now is the role of education, and I mentioned in my last post that I would address it, so here we are. One of the last speakers that we met with during the program was an Arab Christian woman, Elli, who grew up in a Palestinian neighborhood in Israel. Elli attended an Israeli school with a predominantly Israeli-Jewish student body, but also had friends from her neighborhood who were Palestinian, so she grew up in the middle of both worlds. Two years ago, she launched a pilot program called Peace Heroes that consists of a values-based curriculum that is to be implemented over four years in elementary schools. She created the curriculum because she wanted to give children living in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict the vocabulary and ideas to address the conflict and work through the difficulties they face everyday. Peace Heroes teaches students about 60 peace heroes from all different nationalities, genders, ethnicities, religions, and other backgrounds, and encourages them to cultivate values like hospitality, diversity, and nonviolence. It has been implemented in two Israeli schools, two Palestinian schools, and six other schools in Burundi, South Africa, Kenya, and Iraqi refugee camps.

A small part of me was dubious when Elli started talking because it seemed almost too good to be true. She claimed that there had been hardly any backlash from the parents, but the program is still new and it seems like there would be a lot of obstacles. At the same time, I was excited to hear about an effort to prepare the next generation to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through nonviolent measures. This conflict has been going on for over 100 years, since before the creation of the state of Israel, and it seems like a solution is impossible when babies are born into it and children learn (usually unintentionally, in school, at home, through the media, etc.) to distrust, target, or even hate the other. Peace Heroes is not the first effort to solve or improve the conflict through education that we encountered that; we spoke with multiple people about bilingual schools, interfaith school groups, and other attempts to teach peace.

I've started to wonder recently if education is really just another form of brainwashing. That word seems so dirty and ominous, but school is such a powerful institution and the teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults have so much influence over how the students develop. When these adults want to teach the kids to respect their peers, to appreciate different backgrounds, to honor their commitments, and to be patient with themselves, we applaud them for their commitment to bettering youth. However, if these adults were to instead teach the kids to put their own desires before those of others, to only play with kids who looked like them, or to punch a wall when they're mad, we would condemn them for creating little monsters.

Regardless of what we call it, I think it is better to teach kids the first set of values I mentioned, but why should I get to comment on that? Where do teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults get the authority from the decide what values kids are being taught? I would like to see a new generation of Israelis and Palestinians raised to solve the conflict through nonviolent means, but I worry that this questions of authority and decision making regarding education will be too big of an obstacle to spreading curricula like Peace Heroes to more schools.

Thursday, June 21, 2018

A Quick Trip to Jordan

On Monday of this week, our group traveled to Jordan via the Allenby Bridge border crossing. We stayed in Amman until Wednesday afternoon, at which point we returned to Jerusalem. I was really excited about the trip to Jordan because I will be spending the fall semester studying at the University of Jordan in Amman. The three day trip was a perfect taste of what to expect during my time there, and I realized how insufficient my Arabic skills are right now, but it also provided new perspectives on the conflict that we weren't able to get through the programming at Hebrew University and our own explorations in Israel/Palestine.

It seems as though I should be accustomed to the obstacles to mobility that the Israeli government imposes in the name of security, but I was still appalled and frustrated by our experiences crossing the border, both into Jordan and back into Israel. (When we crossed into Jordan, the Jordanian government was also very extra, as the kids say these days.)  On the way to Jordan, we took a bus from the dorms in Jerusalem to the departure gate at the border. As we stepped off the bus, an employee told us to deposit our bags onto two luggage carts, and that we would pick them up after we had gone through the agents inside. Once inside, we waited for about an hour while one professor and one student spoke with the border control agents. Finally, the professor coughed up $40 per participant for the exit fee (he'll be reimbursed at some point) and we were allowed to exit onto the other side of the building, where our bags were waiting for us. Another agent told us to put the bags in the bottom of a bus and get on board.
This picture is not at all related to the
content of this post, but it was taken at the
ruins of the Temple of Hercules in Amman. 

We rode, excruciatingly slowly, along a road for about a mile until we were stopped again. A Jordanian border control agent boarded and collected all of our passports and gave them to the driver. Then we continued for about another mile, until we reached the Jordanian arrivals hall. Upon arrival, another man boarded the bus and asked for payment for every bag that had been put under the bus, despite the fact that no one ever said it cost money to store our bags there. We went through a metal detector and bag inspection point, then waited to collect our passports again. Once we had finally gotten all 17 passports, we piled into a van provided by CIEE (the study abroad company hosting us in Jordan) and drove to Amman. Although the distance between Jerusalem and Amman is only 45 miles, it took us 4 hours to get through the whole chaotic mess.

When we returned to Israel, it took less time overall to get from the CIEE center in Amman to our dorms in Jerusalem, but it was a more frustrating process because of the behavior of the Israeli border control agents. Two students and one administrator were asked to step aside and await further questions; none of them were white. The same thing happened when we arrived in Israel from the United States, and the students had to wait in the airport for multiple hours before they were questioned and processed, so we expected to wait for awhile in the arrivals hall. In the end, they were only detained for about 30 minutes and weren't asked any extra questions, but it was frustrating to witness, because of the blatant racism, and surely even more upsetting to actually experience. Part of what made it so infuriating is that multiple participants in the program have made inflammatory comments against Israel, and one is even on the leadership of Students for Justice in Palestine, which is an organization that supports the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel. However, that student is also Jewish and white, so there was no issue with crossing the border.

Again, this is an unrelated picture of the group at the Roman
amphitheater in Amman as we try to look silly. 
Despite the frustrating border crossing experiences, the trip to Jordan was well worth the hassle as we got to hear from two Jordanian professors and multiple Palestinian refugees living in Amman. The first professor lectured about the struggle for and limitations of women's rights in Jordan, while the second spoke to us about political Islam, including the evolution throughout the 1900s and the role of Hamas in the Palestinian issue. Both lectures were fascinating, especially the political Islam one, but they were also somewhat disheartening, especially the women's rights one. It seemed that every time I felt the statistics and stories she was sharing couldn't get worse, she mentioned one more that was worse than the last. At one point during the lecture, I had to step out to go to the bathroom and give myself a break from the heavy material.

While I was in the bathroom, I started to feel bad about myself. I felt like everybody else in the program was handling the material without an issue, and I chided myself for not having a thicker skin. It was only the next day, after talking to the Palestinian refugees, that I was able to forgive myself for getting upset during the lecture. When we met with the refugees, we immediately launched into a Q&A session. It was the first chance that we had to talk with people who had left Israel/Palestine, and we were all eager to hear about this new perspective. Given the nature of the program, and the personalities of the people in our group, most of our questions related to the hardships they faced as refugees, the unequal treatment they experienced in Jordanian society, and the injustice that had been inflicted on them when they were expelled from their homes.
Here's one more irrelevant picture. It is a compilation
of pictures taken during a scavenger hunt around a
neighborhood in Amman. We made it into a peace sign
because we are in a peace cult. 

There were four women of all ages and one young man, but the conversation was mostly dominated by the two middle-aged women who seemed to be the most eager to engage with us. They answered our questions with stories about their experiences and those of their friends and family, and they largely confirmed a lot of what I have read in textbooks and other academic texts about the plights of Palestinian refugees. I was caught off guard when one of the women eventually diverged from the questions we'd been asking and reminded us that we were the ones who came in and started asking about their struggles. She shared that even though their lives were impacted every day by the conflict and even though they did face a lot of hardship, they also were concerned with other things besides the topics we'd been discussing. She spoke of the joy of getting her children engaged, the pride of having her daughter graduate college, and the way that they maintained their Palestinian culture during every celebration, through food, music, and clothing.

Her comment felt like a reminder that part of humanizing the actors in this conflict means letting them experience the ups and downs of daily life in the same way that I do. There are big differences that are important to acknowledge, but it would also be unfair to simplify the life of a Palestinian refugee to just pain and suffering. Life sucks a lot, and there are a lot of really bad things happening all the time, but sometimes it's okay to focus on the good things, even if they are small.

Sunday, June 17, 2018

Inequalities in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

One of the main reasons that I decided to apply for the Mandel Palagye program was so that I could witness for myself the intricacies of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, rather than just reading about them in textbooks, academic papers, and newspapers. In the history and political science classes I've taken that address the conflict, I've learned about the parallels that can be drawn between the Jewish/Israeli and Palestinian histories, narratives, and societies. For example, both people believe they have a right to return to the land, both people have been oppressed by others, and both people have religious holy sites in disputed territories. Of course, there are many academics and students of the Middle East that view Israel as the oppressor of the Palestinians, and therefore there must be inequalities between the two people. I was aware of these inequalities on a macro level and expected to witness various examples, such as in the checkpoints that separate the Palestinian territories from Israel proper. However, as I've spent the last two weeks observing life in Israel/Palestine, this inequality has manifested itself in ways that I hadn't anticipated. The ones I want to share in this post relate to how we engage with members of the Israeli government compared to members of the Palestinian Authority, and the manner in which individuals are socialized on each side of the conflict. 

Last week, we had the opportunity to visit the Israeli parliament, or the Knesset, and meet two with two members (MKs). Since the moment in April when I saw on a draft of our schedule that we were planning to talk with MKs, I'd been looking forward to it, both for the chance to engage with powerful decision makers and because the visit gave me a reason to show off the business clothes I bought at TJ Maxx over winter break. We had originally planned to meet with an MK from three parties-- Likud, the governing, right-wing party; the Zionist Union, the main opposition, left-wing party; and Kulanu, a centrist party in the current coalition government--  but could only meet with the MKs from Likud and the Zionist Union because of scheduling conflicts. When we arrived at the Knesset, we had to wait in line for our group pass to be approved, then passed through TSA-like security to enter the grounds. Before we entered the main building, we again had to show our passports, but the guard didn't seem very concerned and only checked the first few students' passports before waving the rest of us through. We were led to a swanky conference room, where we waited about 15 minutes to meet the first MK. Some of us happily occupied ourselves with taking pictures of our fancy clothes while we waited, but it did seem a bit strange to wait after we had been hurried through the various hoops to arrive on time. 

Eventually, the first MK, Yehud Glick of Likud, arrived with a young staffer trailing behind him. Glick immediately drew attention to himself with his formidable demeanor and his initial comment that we probably thought we knew how to solve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He launched into a speech about his political views and opinions regarding the conflict, pausing only to hand his cellphone off to his staffer after he got a call from the office of Prime Minister Netanyahu. After about 15-20 minutes, he allowed a few questions; when 30 minutes had passed, he thanked us for our questions, took a picture with us, and hurried out. Glick was followed by Ksenia Svetlova of the Zionist Union, who was also accompanied by a staffer and exuded an air of importance and power. Svetlova was much more popular among our group, largely because of her more liberal political views, but our meeting with her followed a similar pattern as the one with Glick had and she left after 30 minutes, too. After that, we spent a few minutes observing the empty main hall of the Knesset, then headed back to the bus. In total, I think we spent less than 2 hours there, and although everyone quickly changed into more comfortable clothes when we returned to campus, there was a general consensus that we were very lucky to have had the chance to meet with such influential people. 

In addition to Israeli MKs, we have had the opportunity to meet with three members of the Palestinian Authority (PA), all of whom have personal and professional relations with President Mahmoud Abbas. The first one who we met was Bashar Farashat, who serves as a special advisor to Abbas on topics relating to community development and education. On the schedule, he was listed simply as "Palestinian speaker -- Bashar," so there were a number of surprised faces when he shared his role in the PA. The other two officials who we met with were listed on the schedule in the same manner, despite serving as head of the Palestinian security forces and vice-chairman of interaction with Israeli society. Because we were unaware of the true identity of each Palestinian speaker, we were unable to prepare questions ahead of time that may have enabled deeper and more meaningful conversations (although the ones that organically ensued were still engaging). Furthermore, we were all wearing normal clothes (in fact, I had a stain on my shirt during one of the talks) and had the remnants of breakfast and snacks sitting around during all three talks. 

The most notable difference between our interactions with the PA members and the MKs came from the location in which we met them. All three PA members traveled from the Palestinian territories to meet us in a conference room at Hebrew University. Each speaker met with us for an hour-- twice as long as each MK--, but they had to take at least two hours out of their days to account for the commute. Furthermore, they had to go through at least one checkpoint and campus security. All of them arrived 20 minutes early or more, seemingly because they had budgeted extra time for the security obstacles. It was shocking to compare how I felt while interacting with each type of government official-- while I clearly felt that I was on the underside of the power balance with the MKs, it seemed that I was the guest of honor when meeting with the PA members. I'm unsure if this imbalance reflects structural inequalities (i.e. the security apparatus that hinders Palestinian mobility) or the prejudices of the people that organized the program or both or something else that I'm unaware of, but what I do know is that it felt bizarre and demonstrated that the two sides of this conflict are not equals. 

Another inequality that I have been thinking about is the manner in which members of each society is socialized. Mechanisms of socialization constitute a broad topic that I've been curious about for some time, and first realized when I participated in the LeaderShape Institute at the end of my freshman year. One mechanism that seems obvious and the most influential to me is education, especially in elementary school and before. I intend to write another post that explores the role of early education in this conflict more in depth, but for now I will focus on compulsory military service in Israel and the lack thereof in the Palestinian territories. 

The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are a central part of Israeli society, which is understandable for such a young country that had to engage in multiple wars to establish its existence and sovereignty in a hostile region. The vast majority of Israeli youth serve 3 years in the IDF, starting when they are 18 years old. There are ways to delay entry for a year (i.e volunteer work), trade service for volunteer work (i.e. health reasons), or gain complete exemption (i.e. ultra-Orthodox status), but these don't take away from the fact that the compulsory service shapes the common identity of Israeli youth. Of course, a large portion of IDF members do not serve in combat roles, instead working as intelligence analysts, physical trainers, or technicians. 

The variety of postings within the IDF means that Israeli youth have different experiences during their service, as was explained to me by a group of Israeli students at Hebrew University. (They are also all older than the average US college student because they only go to college after finishing their IDF service.) During this conversation, the students all expressed the importance of IDF service for exposing them to Israelis from all over the country; although it is a small country, most students said that they didn't know many people outside their home cities, villages, or kibbutzim. Hearing them talk about encountering new views, I was reminded of my initial reactions to college in the US; I drank up the political debates, new slang, and culinary differences that my classmates offered me, and I see the role that these have played in shaping my world view. 

Many of the students also shared that the first time they interacted with a Palestinian was during their service; some had never even met a Palestinian Israeli citizen or resident. For some of those students, interacting with Palestinians humanized the other, while for others it deepened the image of a terrorist that had been taught to them. I was reminded that while early childhood education is vital to socializing individuals, the moment that a young person begins to identify as an adult tests whether they will accept or reject that education. The students that claimed to have sympathized with the Palestinians did not hold combat roles, while the student who spoke the most about the image's confirmation served as a combat soldier in the West Bank. 

It isn't my place to comment on the value or morality of Israel using military service as a tool for socialization, but I do think it is important to note that this institution of military conscription does not exist in Palestinian society. One of our lecturers mentioned that for many Palestinian youth, university is the first time that they interact with Israelis who are not armed IDF soldiers or hostile settlers. However, similarly to in the US, higher education is a privilege in Palestinian society, and many Palestinian youth do not have the financial means to attend an Israeli university. Furthermore, I don't believe that there is significant coordination between schools in Gaza and in the West Bank, so there does not appear to be a common curriculum, especially as Hamas influences Gaza with its extremist religious rhetoric and Fatah/the PA dictate the status quo in the West Bank. I don't understand Palestinian society well enough to say that there is no other socialization mechanism that almost every member of society engages with, but lack of ideological unity is one of the biggest obstacles facing Palestinians right now. This obstacle is exacerbated by the fact that the institution uniting most Israelis, the IDF, exists largely to counter the Palestinian threat. Regardless of who is responsible for these discrepancies, it is hard for me to see how anyone could argue that this conflict is between two equal players. 

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

O Little Town of Bethlehem

This is where Jesus was born!
Tonight I will be going to sleep happy, full, and hopeful because of my experience visiting Bethlehem today. Due to various reasons related to insurance and liability, my study abroad program is not allowed to bring us into the Palestinian territories. (Although, we are allowed to travel to settlements, which are considered Israeli land by the state of Israel, the United States, and our insurance company, and are considered a violation of international law and officially Palestinian territory by the majority of the world.) However, after we finish our programming each day, we have free time; as we are all adults, we don't have any official rules regarding our mobility during evenings and weekends. Some members of my cohort were eager to visit Palestinian cities like Ramallah, Bethlehem, and Hebron, but I was among those who were more hesitant. Today, however, a group of us finally ventured into the West Bank, both the visit the birthplace of Jesus and to see for ourselves what life in the Palestinian territories might look like.


This is the separation wall
that defines the western
edges of the city. 
There is a lot of tangible and explicit fear within Israeli society regarding their wellbeing in the Palestinian territories. From an objective perspective, this is understandable for multiple reasons: the violent attacks that have been carried out by Palestinians against Israelis; the narrative that is taught in Israeli schools, in which Palestinians are the other and a threat to Israeli prosperity; and the lack of sustained and meaningful contact between Israelis and Palestinians. As my mother will affirm, likely painfully, I have a very low sense of danger. This means that I am very trusting of others, but it also means that I don't think bad things will happen to me, and am often less wary of my surroundings than I should be. I was not concerned for my safety before we went to Bethlehem, largely because I know that, as an American, I am a less appealing target for an attack, fortunately/unfortunately. 


Nevertheless, I went into our excursion with preconceived notions about what Bethlehem would be like. These were based on information from classes I've taken at Tulane, individual research, and the last week and a half in this program. I expected the harsh economic conditions that I've learned about to be more apparent, for people to look at me critically because I am a white American (and therefore stick out like a sore thumb), and to feel less comfortable than I do in Jerusalem. My experience in Bethlehem ended up being the opposite of that. I was amazed by how much cleaner the city looked than Jerusalem, especially East Jerusalem. (Of course, East Jerusalem is also predominantly Palestinian neighborhoods, and as I mentioned in my last post, there are instances of systemic barriers that perpetuate the economic inequality and worsen the living conditions there.) I was only catcalled once, while I have been catcalled multiple times each day that I've been in Jerusalem. I felt completely comfortable walking on the streets, speaking loudly in English, and holding my phone in my hand.
Across the square from the Church of
the Nativity there is a mosque. I've
noticed in multiple cities that there
are often multiple holy sites right
next to each other. 

These observations were all made within 10 minutes of arriving in the city, and I could have returned to Jerusalem in that moment with a sweet taste in my mouth. However, my friends and I ended up spending about three hours there total because of the connection we formed with our taxi driver. To get to Bethlehem from Jerusalem, you can take a bus from the Old City to a checkpoint in the separation wall. After you walk through the checkpoint, you can walk or take a taxi into the city center. We found a man that was willing to drive all 6 of us in one car and we set off. My friend Elli spent the first semester of this year in Jordan, so her Arabic is great; luckily, she was sitting in the front seat and quickly hit it off with the driver, Ashraf. Another girl, Grace, and I chimed into the conversation occasionally, but I don't think we would have gotten along so well without Elli. 


This is one of many graffiti
works on the separation wall.
It was interesting to compare
this piece with the numerous
signs in Jerusalem that
celebrate President Trump.
Ashraf offered to drive us to various places in the city before taking us back to the checkpoint for a fixed price of 120 shekels total (that's less than $34), but between stops extended his generosity even further and invited us to his home to break fast (for Ramadan) with his family. After a few quick looks around the car, we eagerly accepted his offer. After visiting the Church of the Nativity and driving around Bethlehem, we went to Ashraf's house. He explained to us as we drove up a street that all of his family lived in that area-- it was essentially a neighborhood filled with only one family. After admiring the beautiful view of the city from his street, we went inside. He was very hospitable and insisted on having us all sit on the couch while he brought out coffee. None of us touched it, so he brought us into the kitchen to meet his wife, who was preparing the food, and daughters, who were probably playing around and chatting before we arrived. All of the women were very welcoming and hospitable, but I also got the sense that they were either shocked or amused (or both) that 6 random Americans were in their home.


Elli and I tried to talk with the kids, especially Ashraf's 5-year-old daughter, Rahma, but she was shy at first, and our conversation mostly consisted of broken sentences on our part and timid smiles on her part. She was really cute. After about 10 minutes, the food was ready and Ashraf insisted on us helping ourselves first. We were hesitant, because they had been fasting all day and were likely hungrier than we were, but we quickly realized that delaying our own eating would just delay theirs even more, so we dug in. It was a delicious meal of rice, chicken, and a bunch of other things that I have never seen before. I don't know if I'll ever stop being shocked at how good Middle Eastern food is-- the various spices and flavors make it so much more exciting than any other cuisine I've tried. 
Elli, Izzy, and me in Ashraf's living room
eating delicious deserts made specially
for Ramadan.

After eating a lot of food by our standards and not enough by Ashraf's and his family's standards, we moved back into the living room for coffee, dessert, and cigarettes (for the men). Two of the daughters showed off their dresses for Eid al-Fitr (the celebration for the end of Ramadan, which is this Friday) and an upcoming family wedding (which we got invited to, but is after we return to the United States, unfortunately), and we fumbled our way through Arabic conversation as various family members came and went. We even Facetimed Ashraf's brother-in-law who lives in Michigan, which was perhaps the only bizarre moment of the night, as the rest of the time I felt very welcome and comfortable. Eventually we gathered ourselves, made the rounds to express our gratitude and say goodbye, and headed back to the checkpoint. We ended up paying Ashraf more than he had originally asked for, but it still felt insufficient because of his immense generosity. He also insisted on adding us all on Facebook so that if we ever come back to Bethlehem, we can visit him and his family. 

Leila Khaled is a controversial
individual because of her role
in the PFLP (considered a
terrorist organization by many)
and her status as a female
Palestinian freedom fighter. 
Once we left Ashraf's car, it felt a bit like a bubble had burst around us. When we went through the checkpoint on our way to Bethlehem, we had walked through three revolving gates, and that was it. I was expecting the way back into Israel to be a bit more complex than that, but I was unprepared for how it really was. To enter, walked up a long corridor that has no lights, and therefore was pitch black. It felt like I was a cow being led through a corridor in a barn. After that, we went through a revolving gate, walk across a lot, go through another revolving gate, and walk down another cattle-esque corridor. Eventually we reached a room that has a metal detector and security belt, like at the airport. Finally, we walked down another hallway until we reached a couple machines and a manned booth. The machines let Palestinians through who have special permit cards that scan, while those who don't have the cards must wait in the single line that leads to the manned booth; they must obtain approval from the guard there to pass through. There were also two guards on the opposite side, both armed with machine guns, who saw us tourists and waved us over. They took one look at my American passport and let all 6 of us through without any issue. We went through one last revolving gate and finally made it out to the bus stop, where we caught a bus back to the Old City. 

When we headed out for Bethlehem in the late afternoon, I had the Palestinian-Israeli conflict on my mind, in part because we had just gotten back from a long day of lectures and a visit to a controversial settlement, and in part because I'm struggling to think about anything else these days. It was still present during our time in Bethlehem, especially when we visited an area of the separation wall that is covered in graffiti. At the same time, the whole time that we were with Ashraf and his family, we never mentioned politics or the conflict. We said the words "Israel" and "Palestine," spoke about Ashraf's former employment in Israel, and mentioned the intifada, but Ashraf did not seem inclined to talk about it beyond that. Instead, he spoke about the upcoming festivities of Eid and the wedding, his desire for his daughter to be a doctor, his pride in his niece who is a dentist, and his goal of putting food on the table and providing for his family. 

Another work from the separation wall. It says
"But please don't forget to find the human in
your enemy"
I think it's important for me to acknowledge that Bethlehem also receives thousands of Christian tourists each day, and therefore is one of the wealthiest parts of the West Bank. I am sure that if I went to another city or to a small village, my experience would be very different. However, I feel much more confident that both my ability to navigate a new place is sufficient and that others would treat me well. One of my goals in participating in this program is to collect as many perspectives and experiences from people who are related to and impacted by the conflict. Today I learned that one average Palestinian family does not spend all their time thinking about Israeli-Palestinian relations. I learned that this one family does not see outsiders or The Other as a threat, but rather as someone to welcome into their home. I learned the importance of stepping outside of your comfort zone while extending an open hand, an olive branch, or whatever other peaceful symbol you want to use, to others around you. 

Sunday, June 10, 2018

The Tour of East Jerusalem

The past week has been a whirlwind of tours, lectures, insightful conversations, mindless conversations, and a lot of information. I've been struggling to organize my thoughts into coherent observations to share with my fellow students, so the thought of trying to write a blog post has seemed nearly impossible. However, I had an insightful, shocking, and overwhelming Saturday afternoon and I'd like to share my experience.

During the week, we follow a strict schedule with lectures and other activities that were planned by members of the Truman Institute, while the weekends are ours for the taking. On Friday I went to a nature reserve in the middle of the city, where I ate a fig off of a tree and chased a gazelle, and on Saturday morning I tried to attend a church service at St. George's Episcopal Cathedral. (I made it to the cathedral, which was beautiful, but I got the time of the service wrong.) However, the most interesting part of my weekend was Saturday afternoon when I joined some of the other participants on a tour of East Jerusalem that was led by a representative of the Israeli Committee Against Housing Demolitions (ICAHD).

Power over Jerusalem is one of the most controversial topics within the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the status of East Jerusalem has been debated since the war in 1967. During that war, Israel gained control over four new territories: the Egyptian-controlled Gaza Strip and Sinai Peninsula, the Jordanian-controlled West Bank (including East Jerusalem), and the Syrian-controlled Golan Heights. For Israel, the (re)unification of East and West Jerusalem was final, while Jordan and most Palestinians viewed Israel as a new occupying force. Jordan has long-since abandoned claims to the West Bank and East Jerusalem, but Palestinians, especially those living in that area, see East Jerusalem as the capital of their future Palestinian state. (This is why Trump moving the embassy to Jerusalem was so problematic!)

The 1967 War created a new wave of Palestinian refugees, including many who left their homes in East Jerusalem. Many of these homes were seized by the Israeli government and reallocated to Jewish Israeli families. Most Palestinians that did not flee Israeli occupation obtained Israeli residency, but not citizenship, and thus are still struggling as a result of bureaucratic obstacles, as well as the violence and physical oppression that Americans might read about in the media. A big threat to Palestinian wellbeing in East Jerusalem are house demolitions carried out by the Israeli government, which is where ICAHD comes in. The organization uses nonviolent methods to oppose and protest these demolitions and engages in community outreach, lectures, and tours-- like this one-- to raise awareness of these issues.

Some of you might be reading this and thinking that this organization is anti-Israeli, anti-Semitic, or offensive in another way. I would like to clarify that I am unaffiliated with this organization and do not intend to promote it, but I did find it extremely important to hear this perspective as most of the programming so far has been biased in favor of Israel. (Of course, that comes with the territory of doing any program that is based in Israel.) The tour took us through various Palestinian neighborhoods of East Jerusalem and to a couple of settlements in East Jerusalem and just into the West Bank. There were stark contrasts between the living conditions in the neighborhoods versus in the settlements that, again, reminded me of the pervasive inequality Brazil.

The Palestinian neighborhoods were strewn with trash, had low-quality buildings and infrastructure, and lacked sidewalks to ensure pedestrian safety. Most houses had black and white water tanks on top, which our guide explained was because of the unequal and insufficient distribution of water by the Israeli government through the white tanks; a private Palestinian company distributes additional water, which is still not enough, through the black tanks, meaning that the residents of these neighborhoods have to pay twice as much as residents of predominantly Jewish neighborhoods. Finally, the separation wall is looming presence in many Palestinian neighborhoods of East Jerusalem; one shop owner explained to us that he had to stop attending his mosque because the wall separated him from it, but he would still see its minaret peaking above the top.

In contrast, the Israeli settlements that we saw and visited had colorfully decorated recycling bins (one for paper and one for bottles), very suburban-looking houses, and wide, nicely paved sidewalks lined with street lamps. In some areas, the settlements are gated communities that sit directly in between the rundown Palestinian neighborhoods described above. We left Israel proper to visit a settlement in the West Bank called Ma'ale Adumim, which is home to about 40,000 settlers. As we drove down the access road to get there, I was shocked by how much worse the condition of those signs was than that of the highway signs I saw between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. When we arrived at Ma'ale Adumim, it was like entering into another world-- there was a swimming pool, decorative lakes and fountains, green grass (in the desert), palm trees, and signs on the street for a smoothie/health food restaurant.

The tour did not go further into the West Bank than Ma'ale Adumim, which was somewhat disappointing as I was desperate to better understand the mistreatment that I've only read about. However, as a 20-year-old trying to navigate the world around me, I was thankful when the tour ended. It was really difficult to see how much worse the living conditions are for Palestinians in Israel than for Jews in Israel. I was able to recognize that I should be just as critical of the information presented on that tour as I was of the stories that our pro-Israel tour guide told in the Old City, but I wasn't just listening to stories that afternoon. Now that I've had some time to process the emotions that I felt during the tour, I am eager to visit cities in the West Bank, speak with people living there, and try to understandwhat it means to be a Palestinian living under Israeli occupation.

Monday, June 4, 2018

First Day Observations: The Complicated Role of Religion

Today was my first full day in Jerusalem, and it was very enjoyable and insightful, but before I dive into those details, I want to make a note regarding vocabulary. During my time here, I will refer to the area that I am in as Israel/Palestine. I will be including both names because I want to respect both groups that have a claim to the land, and seeing as how none of my ancestors ever lived here, I don't think it's my right to decide which claim is more legitimate. However, I will be writing Israel first because it is the more widely recognized political entity. If this offends you, I am sorry, and please feel free to stop reading here.
This photo is unrelated to this post, but this
is Jesus's tomb, located in the Church of the
Holy Sepulcher. 

Now that I've clarified that, I want to share a bit about what I did today, as well as a couple of observations I made throughout the day. All of the participants met this morning at 8:45 AM and walked over to the Truman Institute, where we will be meeting with most of our lecturers and guest speakers over the next few weeks. There was a welcome breakfast and some opening remarks from the Truman staff who have arranged most of the program. After that, we had two lectures from professors of Hebrew University. The first lecture was a brief overview of  Israel's relationship to the rest of the Middle East and other geopolitical topics, while the second professor addressed the three W's-- What Went Wrong-- regarding the Oslo peace process of the 1990s. The lectures were followed by a quick lunch, then a tour of Jerusalem's Old City. While the tour mostly focused on the Christian and Jewish Quarters, I thought the tour guide did a good job of explaining the complex dynamic that exists between the different groups of the Old City, resulting from competing claims to holy sites and narratives about history. By the time our tour guide told us we were heading to dinner, everyone was pretty excited about the opportunity to sit down and rest for a bit. A group of us walked around the city a bit more after dinner, but when we got home around 8:30 PM, I immediately got ready for bed and am looking forward to sleeping.

Before I go to sleep, though, I want to share two moments that stood out to me today, both of which happened during the tour of the Old City. The first was about halfway through when we climbed up to a lookout point that showed the Western Wall and the Dome of the Rock above al-Aqsa Mosque. As we were walking up to the lookout, I saw a square, brick house with a solar panel, a clothesline full of laundry, and what looked like a couple of water tanks on the roof and terrace. Behind the building stood the golden Dome of the Rock, which was shining in the bright sun. My first thought was that the house looked just like the buildings that you see in favelas in Brazil. It was so startling to me because one part of the scene before me included an image that is so familiar to me, and one that symbolizes poverty and inequality for me, while the other part held one of the holiest and most contested sites in the world.
It was pretty hard to capture it in a picture, but the house I mention
is to the left, while the Dome of the Rock is on the right. 

I eventually realized that the tanks were not necessarily filled with water, that solar panels are often expensive, and that the building I was looking at was in much better condition than the dilapidated houses of most of Brazil's favelas. Nevertheless, the juxtaposition of those two images made me start thinking about the fact that millions of people, both Israeli and Palestinian, are suffering economically because of the ongoing conflict. I won't get into the details of how the conflict hinders both the Israeli and the Palestinian economies, but I will say that many Israelis, especially younger ones, struggle to find affordable places to live as they face the growing housing crisis, while almost 15% and over 50% of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, respectively, live in poverty or below the poverty line. Faced with these facts and statistics, I am fascinated by the fact that the economy does have as prominent of a role in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as issues of cultural and religious ties do. Looking at the brick house next to the Dome of the Rock, I was reminded of how harmful this conflict has been to the livelihoods of millions of people. 


Another unrelated photo, but this is where Jesus
was supposedly crucified. 
The second particularly memorable moment from today was when our group visited the Western Wall. Today was actually my second time going, as a few of the other participants and I ventured to the Old City yesterday evening to browse the market stalls in the Muslim Quarter. I've had numerous secular Jewish friends express to me that the moment in their entire lives in which they felt the most connected to Judaism and to God was when they went to the Western Wall. I don't consider myself much of a religious person, but I have found that when I enter a church, especially an old one, I often feel very calm and very spiritual. I was expecting to feel a similar way when I went to the Western Wall, and I was surprised when I felt nothing during our visit last night. However, when we went back today, my experience was notably different. One of the girls on the trip had brought a pack of sticky notes in her purse so that anyone who wanted to could write a note to stick in the wall. I took one, wrote a prayer on it, and went up to the wall to wait my turn.

While I was waiting, I observed the women around me. There were two older white women who had pulled chairs up to the wall and were praying out of books (I am unfamiliar with most Jewish customs, so I don't know what text it was, but it was in Hebrew). They were dressed very conservatively, with their hair covered, and looked like they were not planning to leave their spot anytime soon. Further along the wall, I saw a black woman wearing what looked like a traditional African dress and hair wrap. Next to her, I saw a young girl fidgeting around while her mom, who wore jeans and a button up shirt, finished her prayer. The women's section** was very crowded, and yet it was relatively quiet and extremely peaceful. Once it was my turn to go up to the wall, I felt a familiar feeling of serenity and spirituality rush through me, similarly to what I feel when I enter old churches (i.e. the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, which was a stop on our tour). Although there were clearly women of different races, nationalities, ethnicities, religions, and even interpretations of the same religions, in such a small space, everyone was able to respect one another and share the wall's holy and historic value. Interestingly, when I left the women's section and was walking back to the group, I felt that sense of peace fade extremely quickly. It made me think about all the animosity that exists between the three dominant religions of the world (not just in this particular conflict), and how Christians, Muslims, and Jews are often pitted against one another, but ultimately, we are all praying to the same God. People often fight with one another because of religious beliefs or claims to religious ties, but these same beliefs or practices can also be useful in bringing people from different backgrounds together in a peaceful manner.

You can see the men's side of the Western Wall on the left,
 and the women's side on the right.

Less than 48 hours have passed since I arrived in Israel/Palestine, but I have already been provided with many opportunities and prompts to reflect on and challenge common narratives regarding politics, history, and religion, as well as my own beliefs about the world around me. I'm looking forward to the next few weeks, which will likely both exhaust me and satiate my curiosity. Thanks for reading!

**For those who haven't been, the Western Wall is divided into two sections, one for men and one for women. I believe that each side was of equal length at one point, but over the years, the men's side has been expanded at the expense of the women's. Now, the women have access to 12 of the 60 meters of the wall. Last night, there were many people praying and both sides were fairly crowded, although there was a noticeable difference between the two sides in terms of population density. Today, that difference was even more striking. I would guess that about half of the men's section was empty, while women were squishing together on the other side of the partition, trying to get as many people to be able to pray at once as possible. I saw multiple women pushing their way through the crowd or slipping into an empty spot seemingly out of nowhere. I didn't get a sense of aggressiveness or hostility towards one another, but it was slightly frustrating to contrast how easily men can walk up to the wall with the effort that women must put in to secure a spot for 30 seconds. There is actually a movement called Women of the Wall, which fights against this unequal separation.

Sunday, June 3, 2018

Hopped Off the Plane at TLV

It's been awhile since I last posted on this blog, and I can attribute my absence to a combination of factors: periods with not enough going on in my life, periods with too much going on in my life, the rise of finsta (for those who aren't familiar with this term, it is a contraction for "fake Instagram," and is a common method for self-expression among my generation), etc. The longer I went without writing a post, the harder it was for me to start writing again. It makes sense, then, that the driving force behind reviving this blog is a pretty exciting update in my life.

I was accepted to participate in the Mandel-Palagye Program for Middle East Peace, which is a study abroad program hosted by Tulane University and the Truman Research Institute at Hebrew University in Jerusalem. The program began in late May with two weeks of classes at Tulane that focused on the history, culture, and politics of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Today, our cohort arrived at Hebrew University, where we will spend the next three weeks meeting with a wide variety of speakers, visiting important sites to the conflict (i.e. an Israeli settlement and a Palestinian village), and engaging in other activities of that nature.

Although I am extremely exhausted from the long trip here (which included meeting on Tulane's campus at 3:30 AM and spending almost seven hours in Newark Airport), I am also very excited for the next few weeks. As a curious and adventure-seeking 20-year old, I am looking forward to exploring Jerusalem and other areas of the country (some of the other participants and I will be going to Tel Aviv for their Pride celebration next weekend!), and as an aspiring Secretary of State, I am excited to learn more about this conflict from people who are directly affected by it every day.

Before I finished my first year at Tulane, I had decided that I wanted to double major in International Relations and Middle Eastern Studies, and I spent most of my second year taking classes in Arabic, Middle Eastern politics and history, and other related topics. I have a number of friends who are also very passionate about this area of study, and I've engaged in many discussions regarding the conflict with them. However, as we are all residents of the United States, our opinions about justice and personal rights, or even which topics are most relevant in this complex conflict, are likely different than Palestinians and Israelis living in this land.

I am looking forward to the adventures that await me over the next few weeks, whether they are academic, political, religious, or social, and I intend to share the observations, lessons, and experiences that I collect via this blog. Stay tuned for more (interesting) posts to come!