Tuesday, December 11, 2018

End of Semester Reflections


My roommate and me after going
running outside on a cold, rainy
Saturday morning
As I sit here writing this sentence instead of studying for my final Arabic exam, I am feeling frustrated with myself for not keeping up with my blog over the second half of the semester, despite there being a lot of good reasons for the negligence. As I mentioned in my last post, almost immediately after I returned from Egypt, I began writing three research papers in Arabic. Each professor required two pages each week to make sure we were pacing ourselves, rather than saving it all to write at the end. It was, of course, a nice feeling when the end of the semester approached and I had finished the first drafts of all three papers before the deadline, but writing six pages each week proved to be a lot of work. At the same time, the rest of my homework only decreased slightly, so I often found myself exhausted after long days of attending lectures, reading academic articles, and trying to write in a sophisticated manner, all in Arabic.

The good news is that the effects of all this work have become clear over the past few weeks of final assessments, and I am happy to brag share that I can write and speak about advanced topics like climate change, refugees in Jordan, racism and discrimination in the Middle East, religious political parties, the relationship between tribes and the king in Jordan, etc. On the other hand, I am really struggling to write in English right now; I think that I have rewritten about half of this post so far because the first try was more similar to Arabic sentence structure.

Some cake at a wedding
that I went to with my
language partner. 
I imagine that I will be having similar experiences when I am back in the United States, although I don't know how strong the reverse culture shock will be. My life in the United States is, in some ways, very different than my life in Jordan. For example, no one in my family and almost none of my friends speak Arabic, and although I have Muslim classmates, none of them wear a hijab (likely because Tulane is not very accepting of Muslim students). Furthermore, I will be spending almost my entire winter break in College Station, Texas, where the only people I know are white Christians. On the other hand, I think that the language is the only huge difference that exists between my life here and my life in the United States. Although women dress more conservatively here, the cold weather over the past month has given me no choice but to cover my skin, and I have always felt comfortable wearing jeans. I have also enjoyed the freedom of mobility that I have, and it comes from the fact that CET houses its students in apartments, rather than with host families.

At the Roman ruins in
Jerash, Jordan
That being said, I think that my time in the United States will be a much needed break from school and learning Arabic. This semester has been tiring and has challenged me more than I had expected it to, but I think it has also helped prepare me for things that I want to accomplish in the future, including diving deeper into Jordanian society and culture next semester. A large part of this semester was devoted to gaining confidence in my Arabic abilities, adjusting to the small changes, and studying so much (!!!!) but now that I am adjusted and feel that I have the cultural knowledge and language proficiency to engage with people, I am ready to discover what is below the surface.


Before I came to Jordan this semester, I had a few goals that I had thought about, but never written down. One of them was to learn more about Palestinian refugees in Jordan. Last year, I read an article that talked about a new shopping mall that represented the blatant class divisions between Jordanians who can afford the items in the mall and the families of refugees that have been living in impoverished camps for generations. I was shocked and disgusted by the information in the article, and I though to myself, "I have to keep an eye out for this mall and avoid it, because apparently it symbolizes inequality." Unfortunately, I quickly forgot about this plan until about a month ago when I came across the same article while researching for one of my papers. When I read it again, I was shocked again, but this time it was because I recognized the mall that was mentioned, Abdali Mall, which I have been to a couple of times. I never went to buy anything because it really is expensive, but it has an outdoor area called The Boulevard that hosts cultural events, like Paris Week.

Some friends and me after baking
a ridiculous amount of desserts in a
ridiculously small and understocked
kitchen on Thanksgiving. CET provided
the materials for us to cook a huge meal
for everyone in the program!
Reading that article again made me realize that I had somewhat failed to transfer the information that I learned in class to my life outside of the classroom. I think that this reflects a bigger struggle that I had in leaving the bubble that I created for myself. Similarly to when I am at Tulane, I spent a lot of time at the university or around it in coffee shops, the gym, or my apartment. I did venture out with friends on the weekends, but it was often to do more touristy things, like shop at a market on Friday morning or visit a mosque or try a new restaurant. The university provided me with many opportunities to observe certain aspects of Jordanian society, such as gender relations or differences in attitudes between younger and older Jordanians, but there is a limit to how much I can study within the walls of the university. I don't feel frustrated about this because I think I learned a reasonable amount during this semester, but I know that I won't be satisfied if I don't complement that learning significantly next semester.

CET offers two programs in Jordan: the intensive language and the internship. I did the intensive language one this semester, but I am considering doing the internship program next semester. I am still up in the air about this because I have heard from some of the students this semester that their internships were disappointing and often felt like a waste of time. I hate the thought of being in Jordan and not learning a lot, and I worry that if my internship is unfulfilling, my entire experience next semester will be that way. However, if I get an internship that matches my skills and interests, I think that I could learn a great deal about aspects of Jordanian society and culture that will be hard for me to access from my bubble of university life. Thankfully, CET doesn't expect me to decide until the beginning of next semester, so I have a few weeks to think it over more. Either way, I intend to seek out opportunities to see different aspects of life in Jordan that I haven't yet discovered.

Sunday, November 4, 2018

My Enchanting Egyptian Expedition

About a week ago I got back from a trip to Egypt and I've been wanting to write about it ever since, but the last week hit me like a ton of bricks and I just didn't have the time. Shortly after I got back from Egypt, I came down with a cold. Eventually I had a quick stomach bug/fever stint, but I'm over that and am focusing on getting over the cold. My workload has also ramped up significantly, as I have 6 pages of Arabic research papers due each Thursday night for the rest of the semester. I appreciate CET's forcing me to work on my papers in smaller chunks, rather than just dying at the end of the semester, but it is also still more overwhelming than I would like. But enough complaining...

The Cairo Citadel offers a beautiful
view of the city.
Ever since I was a kid, I have wanted to go to Egypt. I think that I first learned Egypt's existence through one of my favorite children's books, "The Day of Ahmad's Secret." The beautiful pictures help illustrate a day in the life of Ahmad, a young boy living in Cairo. He travels around the bustling city with a cart pulled by a donkey and delivers gas containers, which sometimes must be pulled up along buildings to reach the top floors. Throughout the day, he looks forward to the evening when he can share his secret with his family. At the end, we learn that his secret is that he has learned to write his name in Arabic. The book, which I revisited when my family was packing up our house in Illinois, does a truly wonderful job of describing the atmosphere in Cairo in a way that transports you to its busy streets and makes you share in Ahmad's feelings throughout the day, especially his anticipation. I was delighted when I finally got the chance to visit Cairo and found reflections of the book in its streets. Mixed in with the cars, busses, and rickshaws were donkeys pulling carts of gas tanks. Across the street from my hostel, I saw construction workers using the same pulley system from the book to transport materials to the top floors of a new building. All around me, I heard people speaking, and shouting, in Arabic, and I felt like I had gone back to a familiar place from my childhood, despite only having read about it in a picture book.

The Great Pyramids of Giza!!!
In addition to the strange familiarity and nostalgia that I experienced, Cairo held other excitements for me. As I moved on from picture books to chapter books and textbooks, I learned about ancient Egypt in school, including the pyramids, the hieroglyphics, papyrus paper, and King Tut. I got a chance to see and learn more about all of these things while I was in Cairo. After debating for a while if we could do the pyramids without a guide, my friends and I decided to book one. (His name was Mady, and he was AMAZING! If you ever go to Egypt, I would highly recommend booking with him here!!)

The Nile River at dusk.
He picked us up at our hostel at 7:45 AM and we drove through Cairo towards the Giza Plateau. As we drove, he started telling us about Egyptian history, but I have to admit that I was so excited to see the pyramids that it was hard for me to focus on what he was sharing. Once we got there and I found myself staring at the Great Pyramid of Giza, I actually cried a little bit. Mady explained to us that, contrary to what many Americans (including myself before this) believe, the pyramids were not built by slaves, but by Egyptian farmers who worked during the four months of the summer season that they did not need to tend their fields. The farmers were preferred because, unlike slaves, they shared the same religion as the pharaohs, and they would keep the pyramids pure. The Great Pyramid of Giza was built over twenty years, but as the farmers only worked for four months of the year, the total work time is really more like five years!

Inside the Great Pyramid!
We all agreed to pay extra to go inside the Great Pyramid, so after our history lesson, we headed in. At first we walked through a spacious stone corridor, at which point I (illegally) snapped the selfie to the right. After a bit, we hit a ladder that led to a very narrow, inclined tunnel/passageway. It was probably about 3-4 feet wide and 4 feet tall, and people were going up at the same time as people were coming down, so it was very, very claustrophobic. After climbing that for a couple of minutes, we came out into a larger passageway that continued to climb up for another couple of minutes. It was more breathable than the first, but the deeper into the pyramid we got, the hotter it got. At the top of that incline, we crawled through a short tunnel and eventually came into a chamber with an empty box where I presume a sarcophagus once lay. The room itself was pretty dark and uneventful, but I got a lot of joy from knowing that I was touching the inner walls of the Great Pyramid of Giza. My friend and I snapped another selfie (still illegal, but I guess the guard didn't mind as much because heard us speak Arabic) that I have chosen not to include because at this point we were drenched in sweat.

After seeing the pyramids, both up close and from afar on a quick camel ride, and the Sphinx, we got a demo on make papyrus paper, enjoyed a delicious lunch of chicken and rice shaped like a pyramid, and drove over to the Egypt Museum. The museum is not very well organized, nor does it seem to have sufficient guards or glass in front of the artifacts, so I was able to touch as many of the artifacts on display as I wanted. I felt simultaneously badass and guilty for touching sarcophaguses and steles and random statues. The museum is also home to most of the artifacts from King Tut's tomb, which are protected significantly more than the rest of the museum and include hundreds of tons of gold in the form of a mask, a sarcophagus, and lots of beautiful jewelry. However, his mummy and one of his sarcophaguses are in his tomb in Luxor, which is eight hours south of Cairo.

In Luxor, between two statues of the
Pharaoh Amenhotep III
For those who don't know, King Tut's actually had very little importance in Egyptian history; he ruled from age 9 to age 18, at which point he died from a leg injury. However, he is famous today because his tomb was never robbed and therefore was discovered with all of the artifacts intact. The reason that his tomb was never robbed is because it was very small and another tomb was built near it, effectively concealing the entrance to his tomb and distracting tomb robbers. After seeing King Tut's artifacts, we went into the mummy rooms, where we saw about 15-20 mummies. It was fascinating to see how intact all the bodies still were, and some of them even had eyelashes and hair. However, it was also a little creepy to be surrounded by a bunch of dead bodies. I also felt a bit intrusive, because these were ancient pharaohs who had their bodies mummified to enable them to enjoy the afterlife, not because they wanted a random, American girl staring at them laying in a glass display case. But, overall, I was thankful for the chance to see them.

al-Azhar Mosque in Cairo
Seeing these historical aspects of Egypt was exciting, and I was grateful that my friends with me were geeking out on the same level as I was. Almost everyone in my group is also studying international relations and/or Middle Eastern/Arab studies, so we have all learned a lot about contemporary Egypt as well. At some point during our tour with Mady, we got on the topic of tourism after the Arab Spring. Each of us had received some sort of warning or backlash from our families when we told them that we were going to Egypt, including my family's kind but unnecessary concern for my safety. Mady told us that the perception of Egypt as a dangerous country has really hurt the tourism industry, which is incredibly important to the economy. As such, since the Arab Spring, many tour guides and others affiliated with the industry have struggled to make a living. The number of tourists in 2017 was minuscule compared to the numbers in 2009 and 2010, but Mady expressed hope for the future as the number in 2017 was higher than the number in 2016. I understand where the concern about safety comes from, but although my time in Egypt was short, I feel it necessary to share that I did not feel unsafe once. I never saw any guns or saw any altercations on the street or worried that I had wandered into a bad area.
Tahrir Square

Also on our list of must-see items was Tahrir Square, which is famous for hosting protests, including ones during the Arab Spring. We had all seen footage from the protests, some of it showing peaceful chanting and some of it extremely disheartening acts of violence. It was surreal when we visited for the first time during our first evening in Cairo. The sun was starting to set, so the whole area had a warm pink/yellow hue to it, and the call to prayer was sounding in the background. Teenagers and young adults sat on the tiles and on the grass chatting and having picnics, while vendors walked around offering cotton candy and corn on the cob. It was so peaceful and normal, and it gave me chills to compare the images I had seen with what was laying before me.

The new Library of Alexandria
My week in Egypt included more adventures in Cairo than what I have describe here, and more adventures beyond Cairo, including a trip to Luxor to see temples, tombs, and other ruins and artifacts from the New Kingdom of ancient Egypt, and a few days of relaxed sightseeing in Alexandria. However, this post is getting a bit longer than I had intended, so I'm going to try to wrap it up. My trip to Egypt was satisfying in many ways. It gave me a chance to reconnect with my childhood, both by experiencing things that I had imagined as a child and by inspiring me to continue to imagine beyond what I got to see. I also got to step outside the classroom to see and experience a country that I have been learning about my whole life, and that I have learned about in such different ways.

Luxor Temple, which was built to
worship ancient Egyptian Gods, then
was used to worship Roman Gods. Once
the Roman Empire turned Christian, a
church was built and now a mosque stands
above where the church used to be. 
Finally, throughout the whole trip, I felt a huge sense of accomplishment regarding my Arabic skills. The Egyptian dialect is significantly different from the Jordanian dialect, not just in its accent but also in aspects of its grammar and vocabulary. Despite these differences, which were at times rather challenging, I was able to navigate my way around a new country without any help from my family or from a program, and that is a first for me. Although people often knew that I was American, they were always impressed by my Arabic skills, and a handful of people mistook me for Jordanian. The trip felt like a concrete measurement of the improvement I've made over the last two semester, and I don't think that I would have realized it if I hadn't left Jordan. However, despite all of the fun I had in Egypt, I was extremely happy to return to Amman, where I could sleep in my own bed and understand about 95% of the things said to me!

Wednesday, October 10, 2018

Reflections of Culture Through Language

One of the most obvious goals and benefits of studying in another country is that it makes you think about your own country in ways that aren't necessarily possible when you are there. Sometimes this manifests in very prominent ways, like noticing that the driving is a bit crazier than back home. Other times, the differences are much more subtle, and when you recognize them, it feels like you just discovered some incredible piece of information. I recently experienced the latter during one of my classes. Somehow we often discuss the differences between the north and the south in the United States, and as there is a lot of pride on both sides, the debate often becomes very lively. As a side note, it is interesting to see how the debate has changed as our vocabularies have developed and our arguments become more complex.

This picture is not relevant to this post,
but it is from a hike I went on last
weekend. It was really fun!
Anyway, we were talking about the stereotypical personalities of the south versus the northeast, and one student wanted to use the word "competitive." When she realized that she didn't know how to say it, she stopped and turned to us. We all expressed understanding what word she wanted to use, but none of us knew it either. Because of the language pledge, we always have to use Arabic to ask our teacher for a new word. I usually enjoy trying to explain the meaning of the word with my limited vocabulary, so I turned to my teacher and said, "It's like when you really want something, or you have a big goal, and you will do anything to obtain it. If there is someone in your path, you say, 'Enough, see ya later.'" She looked slightly confused, and said that she didn't know what I was talking about. Other students chimed in, saying that the word is used to describe people in sports, especially, and often in studies, too. We all burst into laughter when one girl proudly and sassily claimed that she was competitive, while all the Jordanian TAs and our teacher smiled politely, but clearly didn't agree with the humor.

The more we talked, the more confused she looked. Finally, she gave us permission to say the word in English. "Competitive," said the first girl. Our teacher still looked somewhat confused, but wrote a word on the board. She explained that it meant wanting to win, but then wrote "honor" after it, and said it was important to be honorable in the competition. All of the TAs were nodding along with her, while the Americans seemed unsatisfied. We continued with the search for a different word, saying that honorable competition was not what we were looking for. Our teacher asked us why, and we explained that in sports, in college applications, and in job settings, people will do anything to win at the expense of others. All the Jordanians in the room were surprised at this, while each of us kept adding examples of competitiveness in the United States.

Eventually it dawned on me that "competitive" does not always mean "cut throat," although all of the students in the classroom had understood it to be that way. It was interesting that we went so smoothly from defending the culture and experiences of our varying states/regions to agreeing on one interpretation of one adjective, and I felt that it was a very clear reflection of the broader American culture. 

The word for competitive in Arabic is "munafis" which has the root letters "n-f-s." In Arabic, words are derived from three root letters, and all words that share the same root letters also share similar meanings. "N-f-s" means having to do with oneself. My teacher brought up another word with the same root, which was "nafsia." In formal Arabic, it means "psychological" but in colloquial Arabic, it can be used as "self-centered." This led her to introduce yet another word, "mafsum," which literally means "infected," but is used as an insult to someone's personality. Specifically, it is used to describe a person who is nice and friendly one day, but the next day is the opposite and doesn't want anything to do with you.

As my teacher and the other Jordanians laughed about these "crazy" people who were impossible to understand, I noticed that most of the Americans had lost the energy from before, and none of us were laughing. I can't speak for the other students in the class because I didn't talk with them about it, but from the way that my teacher described "mafsum" and her comparison to the word "psychological," I seemed to me that she was describing a bipolar person. I didn't really think much of it, except to wonder if some Americans would be offended by the way she was talking about the topic. There is a good chance that I misunderstood some key parts of the discussion, but it felt a little too close to making fun of mental illness for me to forget it.

Before I came to Jordan, a lot of Arab people I met warned me that mental illness has a much larger stigma than in the United States, and that Arabs don't really talk about mental health at all. As such, the state of my mental health was a big pre-departure concern for me. I knew that I would be dealing with a transition to a new country, including living my life in a foreign language, dealing with street harassment, making friends with other students and locals, adjusting to different expectations for women, and being far away from and in a very different time zone than my support system. To add on to all of that, I knew that I would be without some of the most important coping mechanisms that I employ in my regular life: seeing a therapist; spending time surrounding by beautiful greenery; running outside whenever I feel like it. I worried that after a couple of weeks in Jordan, I would fall into the traps of mental illness that I have worked so hard to keep myself out of over the past few years. (That sounds very dramatic, I know, and I also know that it is not as easy as deciding you don't want to have a mental illness.)

Much to my surprise, my mental health has not been much of a concern for me here. Aside from some discomfort during the first week and a half or so, I have not experienced the same anxiety that I have almost become accustomed to in my life at Tulane. I love Tulane, but there is definitely a big problem with the pressure that is put on students by peers, counselors, professors, and themselves, and that leads us to have unreasonably high expectations for ourselves. Last year, when I was training for a half marathon, volunteering at a local organization, working, holding an assistant position in my sorority, holding a vice president position for another organization, I was also taking 19 credit hours, cultivating my local and long-distance friendships/other relationships, and trying to sleep enough to stay awake for all of that. Now that I am writing this out, I feel ridiculous, but I honestly felt for the entire semester that I was not doing enough. Of course, I was stressed all the time (as my friends can attest) and had multiple breakdowns and struggled a lot with my mental health.

I guess I didn't really think through what the causes of my poor mental health were at Tulane, but the point of me sharing them is that say that most of them don't exist in my life in Jordan. I still spend a lot of time studying for my rigorous academic schedule, as well as maintaining relationships back home and cultivating new ones here, and I try to work out regularly. However, I am not participating in any extra-curricular activities that I could put on my resume. I don't constantly question if I am doing enough now to get me where I want to go in the future. I think it is valid to plan for the future and be mindful of how my actions now will affect my life later, but I feel that it often goes too far. I know that this phenomenon is not unique to me, but rather is something that plagues a lot of high school and college students in the United States. We are constantly being encouraged (or sometimes just told) to prioritize our future, to look for opportunities to get ahead, and to figure out ways to have an impressive and unique resume, and it can be so. damn. overwhelming.

I was originally going to write this post just about my experience with the words in class. It was interesting to observe the way that cultural values or norms were reflected in the language, even if it was subtle. However, as I was writing, I realized there was a connection between that day in class and my overall feelings towards my time in Jordan. Despite the occasional stress of not understanding a few sentences or struggling to express myself in Arabic, I have felt comfortable and at ease over the past few weeks. I don't feel any competition here, and I think that comes from a few things. First of all, as my teacher alluded to in class, I don't think that getting ahead at the expense of others is as common here as it is in the United States. Second, the students in my program are not in competition with one another, and I feel that a friendly and welcoming atmosphere has developed as a result of it.

I just felt like throwing in this picture
of my language partner and me in front
of this sculpture :)
I think that my concerns about my mental health in Jordan were valid, but I didn't have the foresight to know that the competition and pressure that was affecting me so strongly would be left in the United States. I really enjoy feeling less pressure, which may seem obvious, but I have wondered before if I would feel bored with less to do. The truth is that, while I am doing less than I do in my life at Tulane, I am still busy all day long, and my brain is being worked in new, and very tiring, ways. I can see the effects of that work paying off when I read new articles, discuss advanced topics, and think to myself in Arabic. I am proud of the improvement that I have made thus far, and I am excited about how much more I can develop my abilities if I continue to work at it. This desire to improve, along with the relaxed atmosphere and potential to keep learning about Jordan and the Middle East, influenced me to decide to come back to Jordan next semester and participate in CET again. I am excited to see what the next few months hold for me as I continue to embrace my life in Jordan. 

Tuesday, October 2, 2018

Canyons, Deserts, and Petra, Oh My!

I like this picture because my
sunburnt skin matches the
sand behind me :) 
Each morning when my professor walks into class, she asks each student to share what she did yesterday. Every. Single. Day. It is a good exercise for improving the speed of our speech, and was relevant when we spent a day or two review the past tense, but it also showed me that I fell into a routine very quickly; most days I do the same things. In the morning, I get ready for class, eat breakfast, scroll through Facebook or review homework, or something like that. My roommate and I leave the apartment at 8:30 and walk to class, which we have from 9:00 to 1:00. After class, I often eat lunch that I have brought with me, before studying in a coffee shop (often the same one), then going to the gym, or vice versa. Some days I skip the coffee shop or the gym, but I usually do at least one of them. Then I go home and eat dinner, read, study some more, talk to people in the US, and go to sleep.


The routine is a little bit boring, but some days I have so much homework or studying that I feel I don't have any other option but to follow it. At first, the routine made sense because I was still figuring out a lot of things, like where and when to do grocery shopping, what kind of food to cook, how to study for my classes, and things like that. Recently, I've been feeling somewhat bored with my daily life, and I want to branch out; I feel like I am in a CET bubble. I embraced the bubble when I first arrived because I knew that the staff and students would be the easiest and most natural support system, but now that I feel adjusted, I feel ready to dive further into life in Jordan, and I'm not sure how. I plan to ask the program staff if they have any suggestions, so hopefully that will help. I am also planning to go to Wadi Zarqa Ma'in this weekend, which is one of Jordan's many canyons ("wadi/وادي" means "canyon"), with a hiking group that I found on Facebook.
At Wadi Mujib


Exploring Jordan outside of Amman has actually felt easier than exploring Jordan within Amman. As tourism is the biggest industry in Jordan, there are tons of groups on Facebook and tourism agencies leading hiking trips, scuba diving expeditions, and other such activities every weekend, and most of these are for fairly reasonable prices. A few weekends ago, some other CET students and I went with a group to Wadi Mujib, which is a well-known canyon trail. Apparently we lucked out because this year was the best year to visit it in the last 5 years.


It was evident why, as the entire trail was covered in water; in some spots, the water was deep enough that swimming was the only option was continuing on. It was a challenging experience that required swimming against the current, pulling myself up a couple of (small) waterfalls, and avoiding face planting on slippery rocks. Of course, this meant that the return included floating along with the current, jumping off or sliding down the waterfalls, and still avoiding accidents with the slippery rocks. I think we spent about 5 or 6 hours on the trail and it was one of my favorite hiking (if you can call it that) experiences I've had. It felt like I was in another country, and it was so shocking to see so much (somewhat pure) water in the same place in a water-scarce country like Jordan.


My exploration beyond Amman continued this past weekend when the whole program ventured to the Dead Sea, Petra, and Wadi Rum. These are some of the most famous parts of Jordan, and I felt very much like a tourist while we were visiting them. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, but one perk that I get from my daily routine is feeling like I live in Amman, rather than that I am just passing through. I was least excited about the Dead Sea because I visited it in June while I was staying in Jerusalem. My experience was somewhat different; the water was deeper on the Jordanian side which allowed for better floating, but the mud wasn't free.


My friends and me at the Cave Bar,
drinking some some very modern
cocktails at the oldest bar in the world. 
After the Dead Sea, we traveled to Petra. For those who don't know, the city of Petra was the capital of the Nabataean Arabs and a major trade hub from the 1st century BC to the middle of the 4th century BC. Eventually the city dwindled and was mainly inhabited by Bedouins. In 1812, a Swiss explorer "rediscovered" Petra, and today is a major archeological and touristic site. We spent the night in the town around it, which is also home to (according to TripAdvisor) the oldest bar in the world. Of course, I had to check it out, and I kept making jokes about Jesus and his disciples drinking there, too. (Ha ha ha, aren't I so funny??) I made sure not to stay out too late because the next morning we had a 5:30 AM breakfast before heading out to explore Petra.


The famous Treasury at Petra,
which has undergone minimal
restoration, much of which is
to preserve what remains. 
Before going, I had seen pictures of the Treasury, which is one of the more famous structures within the site, and I thought that there wasn't much more to see; I was so wrong. After passing through the visitor's center, we walked for about 10 minutes down a dirt road. There were some ruins here and there, but I wasn't very captivated. Eventually we hit a gorge and walked through that for another 30 or 45 minutes, until hitting the Treasury. The gorge itself had portions of cobblestones, as well as carvings along its walls that showed prayers sites, artwork, and even directions for trade. Beyond the Treasury, we explored common tombs, royal tombs, an amphitheater, the main boulevard for trade, a temple, and eventually, after climbing 800 steps, we got to a monastery and, supposedly, the best view in the world. By the time we were heading back, the sun had really started to beat down on us, and I was happy to leave the heat and the sudden crowds of tourists, donkeys, and camels. Visiting Petra was a much more interesting and fun experience than I had expected, and I kept thinking that I would love to be an archeologist who gets to excavate sites like that.



In the back of the pickup trucks at
Wadi Rum :)
After Petra, we all piled back onto the busses and passed out until we reached Wadi Rum. Again, I didn't really know what to expect, but I was excited to visit the desert for the first time! We got off the busses and hopped into the back of a bunch of pick-up trucks. They all had benches so that 6 people could comfortable sit with all of our stuff piled in the middle. Once we were all in, the drivers took off into the dessert. I had hoped to go really fast, but I think that someone could've easily fallen out if we had gone faster; the fall itself wouldn't have been an issue, but since we were driving in a caravan, the next car would probably hit them...



Wadi Rum :)
The picture truly does not do it justice
Wadi Rum wasn't like the desserts I had imagined, which have golden sand dunes and camels and nothing to block the horizon for miles and miles and miles. The sand was pink and there were tons of rocky mountains, and I didn't see any camels until the next morning. We drove to a couple different places to take pictures and admire the view, including a giant, really tall, really hard to climb mountain of sand. I am happy to announce that I made it to the top, but it was rough, especially after walking 11 miles and climbing 800 stairs at Petra in the morning.





After the sunset, we drove to the Bedouin camp that we spent the night at. On the way, the trucks kind of split up, and our driver let out his wild side. As we were joking around that he should go faster, he hoisted himself out of the car and drove while sitting in the window. At one point he let go of the steering wheel and turned around to wave at us with both hands (see video above). I was having the time of my life, but also felt pretty grateful for the open space of the desert that allowed him to safely veer off track. Once we arrived at the camp, we broke off into pairs and claimed tents for ourselves (which were really more like mini cabins).



The Bedouin camp at dusk 
After a delicious dinner, we all sat around in a circle to listen to some of the men perform a mix of traditional and contemporary songs. There was a lot of dancing, singing, and stargazing, and it was a really peaceful and enjoyable evening. In the morning, a few of us woke up to watch the sun rise, but we had forgotten that the camp was at the base of a very wide mountain that blocked the sun, and it was too far to walk anywhere that we could see the horizon. Despite the lack of sun rise, the time that we spent in Wadi Rum was my favorite part of the whole trip. Eventually we got back into the trucks, rode back to the busses, and headed back for Amman.

The caravan of trucks heading back
through the desert


This past weekend's trip was definitely a highlight of my time in Jordan so far for multiple reasons. I loved getting to see new parts of Jordan, and that I missed a day of class to do it, too. There was also more hiking and admiring beautiful scenery than I ever expected to do in Jordan (clearly I underestimated the natural beauty here!). Finally, I enjoyed the educational aspects of the trip, including learning about the history of Petra and the glimpse of culture that I got from the Bedouins was stayed with.


In writing this post, I've realized that there are two things that are currently missing from my ideal experience in Jordan. First, I want to understand the culture more. I chose CET in part because of the freedom it allows students by having us live in apartments, rather than host families. We have Jordanian roommates and language partners, and they are definitely the easiest ways to learn about the culture that I've found, but they have their limitations, too. Secondly, I miss intellectual stimulation and learning facts in the traditional sense. I have enjoyed studying Arabic, and have learned some facts and some culture in doing so, but I have mostly spent time memorizing words. There is no intellectual challenge, no need to solve a problem or understand a concept. Learning Arabic has its own challenges, but I miss the challenges that I encounter in my classes about politics and history and human interaction. Thankfully, next week I will begin to have two content classes, one about Jordanian society and the other about religious political parties. I hope that they will help with both of these issues by giving me more intellectual stimulation and by giving me the academic background to observe the country around me.

(Below are some more pictures from the weekend...I took (literally) hundreds!!)
In the gorge at Petra
The boulevard at Petra
Rainbow (and maybe royal? I forget...)
 tombs at Petra
Yet another picture at Petra... :) 
The monastery at Petra, at the top of the 800 stairs
Supposedly the best view in the world!! And another 5-10
minute hike after the 800 stairs... 

Tuesday, September 25, 2018

The Holes in My Arabic Instruction So Far

As I mentioned during my first post about my time in Jordan, I chose my program because it is immersive, intensive, and known for its rigorous language instruction. Although I am interested in learning about the culture, the politics, the people, and the food (soooo many yummy spices!!), improving my language skills is my priority for this semester. Of course, those other things come with language acquisition, and it has been interesting to learn about the different phrases, words, or even pronunciations that Jordanians use based on various aspects of their identity (i.e. gender, class, religion, etc.). Much to my surprise, learning Arabic has also made me think about myself and my Arabic instruction in a way that I wasn't expecting. 

In Arabic classes at most American universities, students learn from a series of textbooks called "al-Kitaab," which translates to "The book." I have a lot of complaints about this book, which I will get into momentarily, but from what I understand, it is the best Arabic textbook for English speakers. The widespread use of "al-Kitaab" did come in handy after I switched Arabic professors; I took my first two semesters during the summer at the University of Illinois, then took the second two at Tulane with a different professor. Both universities use "al-Kitaab" and I just had to repeat one chapter before getting back to where I had left off. However, the book has many downsides. Many of the grammar explanations are unclear, which can be frustrating to someone who has never encountered, for example, a case language. 

Furthermore, the organization and introduction of new vocabulary is very confusing. In the first chapter, students learn "United Nations" but it isn't until the sixth chapter of the second book that "to do" is in the vocabulary list. Students encounter "to do" long before then because that verb is used as a template for teaching students how to conjugate other words, but I still find it ridiculous to formally introduce it so late. I have joked many times about the decision to introduce "United Nations" in the first chapter being reflective of American foreign policy interests. "al-Kitaab" was not written by American government officials, but it did respond to the demand for Arabic-speaking Americans who can translate and negotiate on behalf of the United States, and the U.N. is fairly relevant to that (despite what our current president thinks...). However, it didn't really hit me until a couple of weekends ago just how unprepared I am to talk about normal, everyday topics.

My program pairs all students with Jordanian college students to be our language partners. We are supposed to meet with them once a week for 3 hours and just hang out. I've heard from some of the other students that their language partners are unresponsive to texts or don't respect their schedules, but my language partner is great. Her name is Farah, she studies English, and multiple people have asked if we are sisters! A few weekends ago, I had the chance to go to her house to meet her family and have lunch with them. I was really excited, but also very nervous because I had heard that there are certain customs and expectations surrounding visiting someone's home. 

Before I went, I bought some pastries to bring as a gift, and I made sure not to eat much in the morning so that I would have plenty of room to eat all the food I expected would be piled onto my plate. I wasn't sure when I was supposed to give my gift, and I didn't want her family to think that I hadn't brought anything, so I gave it to them almost as soon as I arrived. I was so nervous about doing everything right, so I was very awkward about it, and I realized later that I probably waited more than 3 or 4 minutes before giving it to them, but I still don't actually know what is the appropriate custom. After I arrived, Farah, her mother, and I sat in the living room for a bit, and it was a bit awkward because I didn't know what I was supposed to talk about. I complimented the house a lot, but this was before we had our lesson on how to express wonder and admiration, so I basically just said "ahhh pretty! Wow! Pretty!" and they probably thought I was pretty dumb. 

Eventually her dad came into the room, and I tried asking them if they liked the neighborhood that they lived in, but that didn't pan out into a longer conversation. After trying a few other questions, I finally figured out that travel was a good topic and her father and I discussed a past trip of his to the United States while Farah, her sister, and her mother finished preparing lunch. Once we all sat down, we all amused ourselves with my inability to correctly pronounce, or remember, the names of the various dishes on the table. Farah's mother started to serve me, and I inconspicuously gulped as she scooped about two cups of rice onto the plate, piled on a huge portion of chicken, poured some soup into a bowl for me, and stuck a plate full of a lamb dish in front of me. I was pretty hungry, so I felt hopeful about my ability to finish most of the food on my plate, and decided to pick at the soup and pretend that I didn't understand that the lamb was for me. 

Throughout lunch, I felt a lot of pressure to think of an appropriate topic to discuss, and it felt that most of the responsibility for that was on me. I'm not sure if I was imagining that, or if it's a cultural expectation that guests guide the conversation, or if everyone was just feeling particularly quiet that day. There were a few long moments of silence, but I ended up talking a lot about my family, traveling, my program, and my university (all of which are nice topics, but I felt rather limited). As I tried to think of topics that I had the vocabulary for, all I could think of were things like politics and religion, both of which are things I would love to hear about, but felt inappropriate to bring up at that time. 

At one point, the zoo came up in the conversation and everyone was fairly amused by the fact that I didn't know most animal names. I am very appreciative of Google Images, but I also felt frustrated that I didn't know how to talk about a topic that I associate with young children. At that lunch, as well as in other scenarios, I've run into the same issue when I want to talk about fruits and vegetables, household items, my feelings, or even my daily schedule. (Up until yesterday, I've been going around saying "not good" when I want to say "bad" because I hadn't learned that word yet.) Luckily, most of these topics have been or will be covered during my time with CET, but my experience at the lunch brought back my frustration with my Arabic instruction in the United States. 

I understand the argument for teaching Americans how to discuss politics and religion in Arabic, and I am glad that I can talk about more mature topics, but I think that there is a huge hole in a lot of Arabic instruction in the United States. A huge part of Arab culture is hospitality, but it requires that both parties know how to interact with one another appropriately. I think that the lunch went well, and I am learning a lot by experiencing the culture here, but I wish that things like how to interact with a host or vocabulary for appropriate topics were taught to American students learning Arabic. 

Wednesday, September 19, 2018

My Experience as an American Feminist in Jordan

Before getting into the details of this post, I just want to say that this blog is a place for me to share my experiences. This post may sound critical or like a big, long complaint, but this is about my personal feelings, and I am not making any objective statements about Jordan, its culture, or its people. Overall, I am really enjoying my experience here and I am excited to see what else the next few months bring!

Before I came to Jordan, I spent hours reading travel blogs, TripAdvisor posts, and any other source I could find about traveling in Jordan. My biggest concern was with the clothing-- I didn't want to disrespect the culture or stand out more than was necessary, but I also didn't want to only bring clothing that I didn't really feel comfortable wearing. As most of my internet searches were about women's clothing, I ended up reading a lot about other women's experiences in Jordan. Every single post I read mentioned street harassment, so I expected to experience a lot of catcalling, stares, and other such things. However, I wasn't really worried about it because, unfortunately, catcalling is a regular part of my life in New Orleans, and it was in Brazil, too. Furthermore, when I was in Amman in June, I attended a lecture about domestic violence against women. Although it was incredibly upsetting to hear about how easily brothers, fathers, and husbands can abuse women, the professor also explained that the likelihood that we, as foreigners, would be the target of such crimes was very low.

Over the past few weeks, I have been much more aware of my gender than I expected to be. During my first few days here, I was mostly concerned with my ease of mobility. As I mentioned in my previous post, the beginning of my program was challenging socially because I did not feel very supported in making friends with the other students, but I also didn't feel comfortable traveling places alone because I am a women. Fortunately, after about a week, both the friends and the mobility came, and I am happy to say that I feel much more comfortable going places alone. However, other difficulties that I am facing here because of my gender have continued to weigh me down. For example, although I do go places by myself, I've noticed that people stare at me less if I am in a group, and even less so if there are men in the group. The time of day also impacts the way people on the street react. I live in a fairly conservative part of Amman, and at night there are almost no women on the street.

The catcalling, which often comes in the form of honking, is more disturbing than I would have thought. When taxis honk, it is easy for me to brush off because they probably just want my business, but there have been plenty of honks from regular cars that definitely weren't trying to signal anything to other drivers. It may be because it's louder than just yelling something, but somehow the simplicity of honking also feels more vulgar to me. Most days I don't think too much about this, but today was especially frustrating, and it definitely has been affecting my mood this afternoon.

Worse than the catcalling is the staring. I have a habit of looking back at men who I catch staring, because more often than not, he will look away. However, a few men continue staring, and I am usually the one to look away first. I know it probably means nothing to them, but sometimes I feel like my looking away is giving him the victory. I have taken to wearing sunglasses almost every time I walk in the street, regardless of if the sun is shining into my face or not. I know that they aren't completely opaque, but sometimes I feel like I have a layer of protection that makes me confident enough to check if someone is still staring at me, or even to stare back sometimes. I know this isn't the same thing, but my feelings about the sunglasses reminds me of a moment in "A Thousand Splendid Suns" in which one of the main characters expresses fondness towards her niqab as it allows her to observe others without them knowing or making judgements on her appearance. I often feel that my eyes give me away when I am intently observing my surroundings, and although I am dressed much less conservatively than a woman in a niqab, I enjoy feeling like my judgements are hidden.

Another aspect of this whole gender thing has been the inner conflict over my feelings. On the one hand, I came to Jordan to learn about the country, the culture, and the language. I don't think it is my place to make judgements on any of those things, and I think that being disapproving or judgmental will only hinder my experience here. At the same time, I am a proud feminist and big proponent of gender equality, and I am often very critical of people of all genders (myself included) in the United States when I witness gender discrimination. I know that there are Jordanian women who feel trapped by the societal expectations regarding their behavior, schedules, and clothing, and it has been interesting for me to hear about some of the ways they deal with that frustration.

A sign outside the entrance of my gym
that reads "Men are prohibited from
entering." Most gyms in Jordan are
segregated by gender, or have certain
times designated for men or women. 
I quickly decided to join an all women's gym, as I thought it might be a haven of sorts. In some ways it is; I can wear a tank top and shorts, no one stares at me (except for the occasional glance at my super red, post-workout face), and there is a hair dryer so that no one has to go outside with wet hair (I guess it is considered sexual, but I'm not sure how true that really is). However, the gym is also in a basement with no windows (so that the women don't have to cover their bodies or hair) and, I learned, not totally safe from men. Last week, in the middle of my workout, a women ran into the room with the treadmills and other machines and frantically explained that men had arrived to fix some of the machines. As she struggled to cover her hair with a scarf, she told us that we all needed to go wait in the bathroom (and stand far away from the glass door) for about 10 minutes until they finished. It ended up being more like 20 minutes, and I noticed that a few of the other women weren't happy, but it was all in a very resigned way.

I was pretty frustrated with the whole ordeal because I just wanted to finish my workout, and I didn't care if a man saw me in a tank top and shorts. I understood that I needed to respect the culture, but I think I was also upset because I didn't feel like I was making a choice to do that. Rather, the gym employees had ordered me to hide my body, and I resented the whole situation. I have still been going to the gym since then, and there haven't been any more interruptions from men, but I feel a bit that the haven bubble has been burst.

However, there is a happy ending to my post. Yesterday, much to my surprise, I ended up finding my feminist space in my Arabic class. We spent most of the day talking about violence against women, and despite the heaviness of the topic, it was a really enjoyable class. I felt empowered by the new vocabulary I learned that enabled me to discuss sexual assault, abortion, physical and verbal abuse, and the solutions to these issues. Probably the biggest challenge I've faced since coming to Jordan is not being able to express myself; given the fact that I have only studied Arabic for four semesters and I am expected to speak in Arabic at all times, it is understandable that I can't always say what I want to.

After yesterday's class, I know how to complain about the catcalling and staring I encounter everyday. I also got to hear my classmates express their frustrations with mistreatment of women, both in Jordan and the United States, and it made me feel closer to them. Finally, discussing these topics with my professor, my TAs, and CET's academic director (who was in the room at the time), all of whom are Jordanian women, made me feel like I can continue to find Jordanian women who are just as frustrated as me. Finding people to talk to and be in solidarity with gave me much more peace of mind than the women's gym did, and I feel like that feeling can't and won't be burst as easily.

Monday, September 3, 2018

أهلا و سهلا الى الأردن! !Welcome to Jordan

marHaba, keifik? مرحبا، كيفك؟
This is how you say "Hello, how are you?" in Arabic, which is one of about five phrases that I have felt confident enough to use over the past few days. I arrived in Amman, Jordan, in the afternoon of Wednesday, August 29th, but it feels like I've been here for three weeks! I know that the next few months are going to fly by, and before I know it, I'll be boarding a plane again to head back to the United States. I feel strange thinking about my departure because it feels simultaneously really soon and really far away. Over the last few days, I've already come to feel much more comfortable in my life in Amman, and I wonder if my adjustment will eventually plateau, or if I will be convinced that I am Jordanian by the time I leave.

This is my interpretation of
the phrase, "Fake it 'til you
make it," which has always
been one of my favorites.
I think I'll be channeling
that mentality a lot over the
next couple of weeks!
One thing that will definitely continue to improve while I am here is my Arabic. I am studying through a program called CET Jordan: Intensive Language. As the name suggests, this program is all about language acquisition, and it is known for being one of the most rigorous Arabic programs in the country. This rigor is achieved through enforcing a 24/7 Arabic language pledge, as well as through grammar courses and content electives taught entirely in Arabic, Jordanian roommates, and Jordanian language partners. Tulane does not have a partnership with CET and sends most students to Jordan with CIEE, which is also a great program, but is less focused on language acquisition, so I had to petition the university to allow me to study with CET. Although it was completely my choice, my housemates and friends in New Orleans can attest that I have been freaking out, for lack of a better word, about my impending failure at communicating with anyone in this country for the past few months.

On my way here, I flew directly from Chicago to Amman. There were several other students from my program on the same flight, and I met some of them before we even boarded the plane. The plane ride was 11 hours long, so I had plenty of time to worry over how I would communicate with the other students when I arrived. I played out various introductory conversations over and over again in my head, trying to figure out the best way to tell my stories without running into unfamiliar words. This all turned out to be unnecessary, as it was quickly announced that the language pledge wouldn't start for a few more days, and that we were free to speak in English with one another.

This is my side of the
room, with some pictures
of friends and family :)
About 25 of us landed around the same time, so a bus drove us all to the student apartments, where we were all given our room assignments; I live in a two-bedroom apartment with Kathryn, an American girl from Kentucky, and a Jordanian college student, who will be moving in next week. The apartments are split by gender, and all the female students live in one building while all the male students (except for one) live in another. There are also families and some staff members that live in our buildings, but, at least in the girls' building, it is mostly CET students. One the first night, most of the students in the program got dinner around the apartment buildings, which made it easy to meet a lot of people. It was really just a blur of names, majors, university names, and other random facts that seemed worthwhile to ask about, and many of these conversations were repeated over the next couple of days.


The former Jordanian Parliament,
where the constitution was
signed in 1952. It was a stop
on my city tour.
The next day, we had a quick orientation and a tour of the city, as well as a trip to a grocery store. Friday, however, was not as fun, as we all took language placement exams in our apartments. I knew that it would be hard, as it is designed to test people with all levels and backgrounds, but I didn't realize how bad I would feel about myself afterwards. I estimate that I finished about a third or a half of the test, and there were various words and grammatical concepts that I was unfamiliar with. It was hard for me to process not doing well on an Arabic test, as I have never scored below an A on a single Arabic exam over the last four semesters. The exam ended at 12:30, and after that, we didn't have anything scheduled for us until Sunday morning.



My low spirits from the exam continued to drop when I began to feel overwhelmed by the immense amount of free time that lay before me. Alarm bells started to go off in my head as I wondered if I would spend the next day and a half locked in my room with no one to talk to and nothing to do. "Will I be the loser girl who doesn't make any friends because no one wants to hang out with me and everyone else is already friends with each other and out and about having fun and it'll be so awkward on Sunday when everyone asks what I did this weekend and I have to lie and make something up or admit that I'm a total loser and--" My mom, my brother, and some friends back home can vouch for my small breakdown, which I am happy to say I overcame.
This is the hole we
climbed through...

Kathryn and I set out in search of a women's gym (many are segregated by gender) and found one near the university that charges around $100 for a 3-month membership. We had a bit of an adventure on our way there and on the way back, as we had to cross one of the bigger and busier streets in Jordan. On each side, there are about three lanes, and there is a fence running through the middle of the road. We found a hole in the fence, so when the traffic let up a bit, we sprinted across, climbed through the hole, and waited for a chance to run across again. When we told others about the gym and contemplated if the danger of getting there was worth it, we learned that there is, in fact, and underground passage that allows pedestrians to cross to the other side safely. 



After the kickboxing class! 
On Saturday morning, some other girls and I went to a kickboxing class at SheFighter, the first female, self-defense gym in the Middle East. In the evening we got a bigger group together and went back to Rainbow Street. I was thankful for the ability to speak in English, because I don't think I could have laughed with the other girls about finding the right angle for a picture or discussed the cultural differences between the United States and Canada if it had all been in Arabic. On Sunday, we finally had our full-day orientation, and the program staff basically just threw a lot of information at us about a lot of different topics. (If you have any questions now, Mom, I can finally answer them!!) My brain felt a bit like mush, and I spent the rest of the day/evening in the apartment, trying to rest as well as mentally and emotionally prepare myself for the oral exam that I took today.

Today is the last full day of orientation, as our grammar courses will begin tomorrow morning. Before the classes can begin, however, we all need to be placed in our correct Arabic levels. Arabic is usually taught to Americans in its formal form, known as fusHa (فصحى), but each country speaks its own spoken dialect, known as amiya (عامية), and different professors emphasize its importance to varying degrees. My amiya education has been rather inadequate, so I was very nervous for my oral exam this afternoon, especially because each student had to sign their language pledge after completing the exam. Kathryn took hers this morning, so when she came home after, she could only speak to me in Arabic. I tried to respond in Arabic, for both of our sakes, but I let myself cheat here and there. However, I have finished the oral exam, and I am in full Arabic mode now. (Well, almost, considering I am writing this in English. But it is allowed, so it's fine.)

A coffee shop that I went to
during my city tour, and returned
to with some other girls over
the weekend. Coffee shops are
really popular here!
I am surprised by how much harder it is to communicate with each other now, but the last couple of hours have also been amusing because of the creativity that other students have put into communicating their points. Kathryn noted that we seem to understand each other fairly well, but that our Jordanian roommate may not understand us as easily. I think our mutual understanding stems from the fact that our vocabularies are similar, and that the way we approach the language is similar. If she describes something to me, I'll understand what she is trying to say, but I may not know the word for it, either. My hope is that when our Jordanian roommate moves in, she can help broaden our vocabulary by teaching us the word in those instances.

Tonight we have a big welcome dinner for everyone in the program, but as we have all signed the language pledge, it will be entirely in Arabic. There will likely be a lot of "umm" and "uhh" and "shuu haza?" (شو هذا؟) which is Arabic for "What is this?" However, I don't feel as nervous as I had been on the flight over here, because I feel a lot more comfortable with other students in the program. It's a big group, with more than 40 students, so I haven't gotten to know everyone yet, but I am thankful that the language pledge started after I had to chance to bond with some of the other students, and to get past the initial introductory conversations. I would have been able to do them without any problem, but I know now that I really will be diving into Arabic from now on, and I'm excited to see where this semester takes me!







Thursday, June 28, 2018

Education in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

This blog post is long overdue; I meant to write it before I left Israel, but that was almost a week ago, and here I am sitting in a coffee shop in New Orleans. I probably wouldn't be here if my friend, Julia, hadn't motivated me with her offer of an air-conditioned ride and unobtrusive company. Part of the reason that this last post has been so difficult to write is that I still have so many thoughts about this conflict bouncing around in my mind and it's hard to focus in on them when I have distractions like mattress deliveries, grocery shopping, and friends' housewarming parties calling my name. It's somewhat unnerving how easily I have settled back into my life in New Orleans; although I was only in Israel/Palestine for three weeks, the conversations I was having and the activities I was engaging in were widely different from my everyday life, and I expected to need more time to transition back.

The idea that is shining the strongest in my head right now is the role of education, and I mentioned in my last post that I would address it, so here we are. One of the last speakers that we met with during the program was an Arab Christian woman, Elli, who grew up in a Palestinian neighborhood in Israel. Elli attended an Israeli school with a predominantly Israeli-Jewish student body, but also had friends from her neighborhood who were Palestinian, so she grew up in the middle of both worlds. Two years ago, she launched a pilot program called Peace Heroes that consists of a values-based curriculum that is to be implemented over four years in elementary schools. She created the curriculum because she wanted to give children living in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict the vocabulary and ideas to address the conflict and work through the difficulties they face everyday. Peace Heroes teaches students about 60 peace heroes from all different nationalities, genders, ethnicities, religions, and other backgrounds, and encourages them to cultivate values like hospitality, diversity, and nonviolence. It has been implemented in two Israeli schools, two Palestinian schools, and six other schools in Burundi, South Africa, Kenya, and Iraqi refugee camps.

A small part of me was dubious when Elli started talking because it seemed almost too good to be true. She claimed that there had been hardly any backlash from the parents, but the program is still new and it seems like there would be a lot of obstacles. At the same time, I was excited to hear about an effort to prepare the next generation to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through nonviolent measures. This conflict has been going on for over 100 years, since before the creation of the state of Israel, and it seems like a solution is impossible when babies are born into it and children learn (usually unintentionally, in school, at home, through the media, etc.) to distrust, target, or even hate the other. Peace Heroes is not the first effort to solve or improve the conflict through education that we encountered that; we spoke with multiple people about bilingual schools, interfaith school groups, and other attempts to teach peace.

I've started to wonder recently if education is really just another form of brainwashing. That word seems so dirty and ominous, but school is such a powerful institution and the teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults have so much influence over how the students develop. When these adults want to teach the kids to respect their peers, to appreciate different backgrounds, to honor their commitments, and to be patient with themselves, we applaud them for their commitment to bettering youth. However, if these adults were to instead teach the kids to put their own desires before those of others, to only play with kids who looked like them, or to punch a wall when they're mad, we would condemn them for creating little monsters.

Regardless of what we call it, I think it is better to teach kids the first set of values I mentioned, but why should I get to comment on that? Where do teachers, administrators, textbook writers, coaches, and other adults get the authority from the decide what values kids are being taught? I would like to see a new generation of Israelis and Palestinians raised to solve the conflict through nonviolent means, but I worry that this questions of authority and decision making regarding education will be too big of an obstacle to spreading curricula like Peace Heroes to more schools.