Last week, we had the opportunity to visit the Israeli parliament, or the Knesset, and meet two with two members (MKs). Since the moment in April when I saw on a draft of our schedule that we were planning to talk with MKs, I'd been looking forward to it, both for the chance to engage with powerful decision makers and because the visit gave me a reason to show off the business clothes I bought at TJ Maxx over winter break. We had originally planned to meet with an MK from three parties-- Likud, the governing, right-wing party; the Zionist Union, the main opposition, left-wing party; and Kulanu, a centrist party in the current coalition government-- but could only meet with the MKs from Likud and the Zionist Union because of scheduling conflicts. When we arrived at the Knesset, we had to wait in line for our group pass to be approved, then passed through TSA-like security to enter the grounds. Before we entered the main building, we again had to show our passports, but the guard didn't seem very concerned and only checked the first few students' passports before waving the rest of us through. We were led to a swanky conference room, where we waited about 15 minutes to meet the first MK. Some of us happily occupied ourselves with taking pictures of our fancy clothes while we waited, but it did seem a bit strange to wait after we had been hurried through the various hoops to arrive on time.
Eventually, the first MK, Yehud Glick of Likud, arrived with a young staffer trailing behind him. Glick immediately drew attention to himself with his formidable demeanor and his initial comment that we probably thought we knew how to solve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He launched into a speech about his political views and opinions regarding the conflict, pausing only to hand his cellphone off to his staffer after he got a call from the office of Prime Minister Netanyahu. After about 15-20 minutes, he allowed a few questions; when 30 minutes had passed, he thanked us for our questions, took a picture with us, and hurried out. Glick was followed by Ksenia Svetlova of the Zionist Union, who was also accompanied by a staffer and exuded an air of importance and power. Svetlova was much more popular among our group, largely because of her more liberal political views, but our meeting with her followed a similar pattern as the one with Glick had and she left after 30 minutes, too. After that, we spent a few minutes observing the empty main hall of the Knesset, then headed back to the bus. In total, I think we spent less than 2 hours there, and although everyone quickly changed into more comfortable clothes when we returned to campus, there was a general consensus that we were very lucky to have had the chance to meet with such influential people.
In addition to Israeli MKs, we have had the opportunity to meet with three members of the Palestinian Authority (PA), all of whom have personal and professional relations with President Mahmoud Abbas. The first one who we met was Bashar Farashat, who serves as a special advisor to Abbas on topics relating to community development and education. On the schedule, he was listed simply as "Palestinian speaker -- Bashar," so there were a number of surprised faces when he shared his role in the PA. The other two officials who we met with were listed on the schedule in the same manner, despite serving as head of the Palestinian security forces and vice-chairman of interaction with Israeli society. Because we were unaware of the true identity of each Palestinian speaker, we were unable to prepare questions ahead of time that may have enabled deeper and more meaningful conversations (although the ones that organically ensued were still engaging). Furthermore, we were all wearing normal clothes (in fact, I had a stain on my shirt during one of the talks) and had the remnants of breakfast and snacks sitting around during all three talks.
The most notable difference between our interactions with the PA members and the MKs came from the location in which we met them. All three PA members traveled from the Palestinian territories to meet us in a conference room at Hebrew University. Each speaker met with us for an hour-- twice as long as each MK--, but they had to take at least two hours out of their days to account for the commute. Furthermore, they had to go through at least one checkpoint and campus security. All of them arrived 20 minutes early or more, seemingly because they had budgeted extra time for the security obstacles. It was shocking to compare how I felt while interacting with each type of government official-- while I clearly felt that I was on the underside of the power balance with the MKs, it seemed that I was the guest of honor when meeting with the PA members. I'm unsure if this imbalance reflects structural inequalities (i.e. the security apparatus that hinders Palestinian mobility) or the prejudices of the people that organized the program or both or something else that I'm unaware of, but what I do know is that it felt bizarre and demonstrated that the two sides of this conflict are not equals.
Another inequality that I have been thinking about is the manner in which members of each society is socialized. Mechanisms of socialization constitute a broad topic that I've been curious about for some time, and first realized when I participated in the LeaderShape Institute at the end of my freshman year. One mechanism that seems obvious and the most influential to me is education, especially in elementary school and before. I intend to write another post that explores the role of early education in this conflict more in depth, but for now I will focus on compulsory military service in Israel and the lack thereof in the Palestinian territories.
The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are a central part of Israeli society, which is understandable for such a young country that had to engage in multiple wars to establish its existence and sovereignty in a hostile region. The vast majority of Israeli youth serve 3 years in the IDF, starting when they are 18 years old. There are ways to delay entry for a year (i.e volunteer work), trade service for volunteer work (i.e. health reasons), or gain complete exemption (i.e. ultra-Orthodox status), but these don't take away from the fact that the compulsory service shapes the common identity of Israeli youth. Of course, a large portion of IDF members do not serve in combat roles, instead working as intelligence analysts, physical trainers, or technicians.
The variety of postings within the IDF means that Israeli youth have different experiences during their service, as was explained to me by a group of Israeli students at Hebrew University. (They are also all older than the average US college student because they only go to college after finishing their IDF service.) During this conversation, the students all expressed the importance of IDF service for exposing them to Israelis from all over the country; although it is a small country, most students said that they didn't know many people outside their home cities, villages, or kibbutzim. Hearing them talk about encountering new views, I was reminded of my initial reactions to college in the US; I drank up the political debates, new slang, and culinary differences that my classmates offered me, and I see the role that these have played in shaping my world view.
Many of the students also shared that the first time they interacted with a Palestinian was during their service; some had never even met a Palestinian Israeli citizen or resident. For some of those students, interacting with Palestinians humanized the other, while for others it deepened the image of a terrorist that had been taught to them. I was reminded that while early childhood education is vital to socializing individuals, the moment that a young person begins to identify as an adult tests whether they will accept or reject that education. The students that claimed to have sympathized with the Palestinians did not hold combat roles, while the student who spoke the most about the image's confirmation served as a combat soldier in the West Bank.
It isn't my place to comment on the value or morality of Israel using military service as a tool for socialization, but I do think it is important to note that this institution of military conscription does not exist in Palestinian society. One of our lecturers mentioned that for many Palestinian youth, university is the first time that they interact with Israelis who are not armed IDF soldiers or hostile settlers. However, similarly to in the US, higher education is a privilege in Palestinian society, and many Palestinian youth do not have the financial means to attend an Israeli university. Furthermore, I don't believe that there is significant coordination between schools in Gaza and in the West Bank, so there does not appear to be a common curriculum, especially as Hamas influences Gaza with its extremist religious rhetoric and Fatah/the PA dictate the status quo in the West Bank. I don't understand Palestinian society well enough to say that there is no other socialization mechanism that almost every member of society engages with, but lack of ideological unity is one of the biggest obstacles facing Palestinians right now. This obstacle is exacerbated by the fact that the institution uniting most Israelis, the IDF, exists largely to counter the Palestinian threat. Regardless of who is responsible for these discrepancies, it is hard for me to see how anyone could argue that this conflict is between two equal players.
Isabel, I really appreciate your way of thinking out loud, and taking us to "see" what you are seeing. We, too, are having a very thoughtful Palestine/Israeli experience.
ReplyDeletexxxVovoP
Isabel, your observations of ways that inequalities between Israelis and Palestinians play out in everyday life are interesting. I'm wondering if you felt that the discussions with the representatives of the PA were qualitatively different in any way from the interactions you had with the MKs. Given the trouble that the PA reps had to go through to meet with a group of outsiders such as yours, what do you think made it worth their while?
ReplyDeleteI will be very curious to know what you discover about how Palestinian youth in different contexts (West Bank, Gaza, Jordan, etc.) are socialized. It may not happen in the same way everywhere, but I would imagine there are various factors at work. I think you are right about the role that the IDF and national service as young adults plays among Israelis (the novel you and I recently read was very indicative in that regard too). Keep writing!