Sunday, June 10, 2018

The Tour of East Jerusalem

The past week has been a whirlwind of tours, lectures, insightful conversations, mindless conversations, and a lot of information. I've been struggling to organize my thoughts into coherent observations to share with my fellow students, so the thought of trying to write a blog post has seemed nearly impossible. However, I had an insightful, shocking, and overwhelming Saturday afternoon and I'd like to share my experience.

During the week, we follow a strict schedule with lectures and other activities that were planned by members of the Truman Institute, while the weekends are ours for the taking. On Friday I went to a nature reserve in the middle of the city, where I ate a fig off of a tree and chased a gazelle, and on Saturday morning I tried to attend a church service at St. George's Episcopal Cathedral. (I made it to the cathedral, which was beautiful, but I got the time of the service wrong.) However, the most interesting part of my weekend was Saturday afternoon when I joined some of the other participants on a tour of East Jerusalem that was led by a representative of the Israeli Committee Against Housing Demolitions (ICAHD).

Power over Jerusalem is one of the most controversial topics within the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the status of East Jerusalem has been debated since the war in 1967. During that war, Israel gained control over four new territories: the Egyptian-controlled Gaza Strip and Sinai Peninsula, the Jordanian-controlled West Bank (including East Jerusalem), and the Syrian-controlled Golan Heights. For Israel, the (re)unification of East and West Jerusalem was final, while Jordan and most Palestinians viewed Israel as a new occupying force. Jordan has long-since abandoned claims to the West Bank and East Jerusalem, but Palestinians, especially those living in that area, see East Jerusalem as the capital of their future Palestinian state. (This is why Trump moving the embassy to Jerusalem was so problematic!)

The 1967 War created a new wave of Palestinian refugees, including many who left their homes in East Jerusalem. Many of these homes were seized by the Israeli government and reallocated to Jewish Israeli families. Most Palestinians that did not flee Israeli occupation obtained Israeli residency, but not citizenship, and thus are still struggling as a result of bureaucratic obstacles, as well as the violence and physical oppression that Americans might read about in the media. A big threat to Palestinian wellbeing in East Jerusalem are house demolitions carried out by the Israeli government, which is where ICAHD comes in. The organization uses nonviolent methods to oppose and protest these demolitions and engages in community outreach, lectures, and tours-- like this one-- to raise awareness of these issues.

Some of you might be reading this and thinking that this organization is anti-Israeli, anti-Semitic, or offensive in another way. I would like to clarify that I am unaffiliated with this organization and do not intend to promote it, but I did find it extremely important to hear this perspective as most of the programming so far has been biased in favor of Israel. (Of course, that comes with the territory of doing any program that is based in Israel.) The tour took us through various Palestinian neighborhoods of East Jerusalem and to a couple of settlements in East Jerusalem and just into the West Bank. There were stark contrasts between the living conditions in the neighborhoods versus in the settlements that, again, reminded me of the pervasive inequality Brazil.

The Palestinian neighborhoods were strewn with trash, had low-quality buildings and infrastructure, and lacked sidewalks to ensure pedestrian safety. Most houses had black and white water tanks on top, which our guide explained was because of the unequal and insufficient distribution of water by the Israeli government through the white tanks; a private Palestinian company distributes additional water, which is still not enough, through the black tanks, meaning that the residents of these neighborhoods have to pay twice as much as residents of predominantly Jewish neighborhoods. Finally, the separation wall is looming presence in many Palestinian neighborhoods of East Jerusalem; one shop owner explained to us that he had to stop attending his mosque because the wall separated him from it, but he would still see its minaret peaking above the top.

In contrast, the Israeli settlements that we saw and visited had colorfully decorated recycling bins (one for paper and one for bottles), very suburban-looking houses, and wide, nicely paved sidewalks lined with street lamps. In some areas, the settlements are gated communities that sit directly in between the rundown Palestinian neighborhoods described above. We left Israel proper to visit a settlement in the West Bank called Ma'ale Adumim, which is home to about 40,000 settlers. As we drove down the access road to get there, I was shocked by how much worse the condition of those signs was than that of the highway signs I saw between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. When we arrived at Ma'ale Adumim, it was like entering into another world-- there was a swimming pool, decorative lakes and fountains, green grass (in the desert), palm trees, and signs on the street for a smoothie/health food restaurant.

The tour did not go further into the West Bank than Ma'ale Adumim, which was somewhat disappointing as I was desperate to better understand the mistreatment that I've only read about. However, as a 20-year-old trying to navigate the world around me, I was thankful when the tour ended. It was really difficult to see how much worse the living conditions are for Palestinians in Israel than for Jews in Israel. I was able to recognize that I should be just as critical of the information presented on that tour as I was of the stories that our pro-Israel tour guide told in the Old City, but I wasn't just listening to stories that afternoon. Now that I've had some time to process the emotions that I felt during the tour, I am eager to visit cities in the West Bank, speak with people living there, and try to understandwhat it means to be a Palestinian living under Israeli occupation.

1 comment:

  1. Bel, thanks for this report. While you must remain mindful of the interests that inform any one perspective on the conflict, it is good to continue to seek out different ways of looking at it, and touring different neighborhoods to see for yourself how people live is a good way to do that. I am particularly struck by the inequalities in access to water -- so important to living decently in these conditions! Keep writing!

    ReplyDelete