Wednesday, September 19, 2018

My Experience as an American Feminist in Jordan

Before getting into the details of this post, I just want to say that this blog is a place for me to share my experiences. This post may sound critical or like a big, long complaint, but this is about my personal feelings, and I am not making any objective statements about Jordan, its culture, or its people. Overall, I am really enjoying my experience here and I am excited to see what else the next few months bring!

Before I came to Jordan, I spent hours reading travel blogs, TripAdvisor posts, and any other source I could find about traveling in Jordan. My biggest concern was with the clothing-- I didn't want to disrespect the culture or stand out more than was necessary, but I also didn't want to only bring clothing that I didn't really feel comfortable wearing. As most of my internet searches were about women's clothing, I ended up reading a lot about other women's experiences in Jordan. Every single post I read mentioned street harassment, so I expected to experience a lot of catcalling, stares, and other such things. However, I wasn't really worried about it because, unfortunately, catcalling is a regular part of my life in New Orleans, and it was in Brazil, too. Furthermore, when I was in Amman in June, I attended a lecture about domestic violence against women. Although it was incredibly upsetting to hear about how easily brothers, fathers, and husbands can abuse women, the professor also explained that the likelihood that we, as foreigners, would be the target of such crimes was very low.

Over the past few weeks, I have been much more aware of my gender than I expected to be. During my first few days here, I was mostly concerned with my ease of mobility. As I mentioned in my previous post, the beginning of my program was challenging socially because I did not feel very supported in making friends with the other students, but I also didn't feel comfortable traveling places alone because I am a women. Fortunately, after about a week, both the friends and the mobility came, and I am happy to say that I feel much more comfortable going places alone. However, other difficulties that I am facing here because of my gender have continued to weigh me down. For example, although I do go places by myself, I've noticed that people stare at me less if I am in a group, and even less so if there are men in the group. The time of day also impacts the way people on the street react. I live in a fairly conservative part of Amman, and at night there are almost no women on the street.

The catcalling, which often comes in the form of honking, is more disturbing than I would have thought. When taxis honk, it is easy for me to brush off because they probably just want my business, but there have been plenty of honks from regular cars that definitely weren't trying to signal anything to other drivers. It may be because it's louder than just yelling something, but somehow the simplicity of honking also feels more vulgar to me. Most days I don't think too much about this, but today was especially frustrating, and it definitely has been affecting my mood this afternoon.

Worse than the catcalling is the staring. I have a habit of looking back at men who I catch staring, because more often than not, he will look away. However, a few men continue staring, and I am usually the one to look away first. I know it probably means nothing to them, but sometimes I feel like my looking away is giving him the victory. I have taken to wearing sunglasses almost every time I walk in the street, regardless of if the sun is shining into my face or not. I know that they aren't completely opaque, but sometimes I feel like I have a layer of protection that makes me confident enough to check if someone is still staring at me, or even to stare back sometimes. I know this isn't the same thing, but my feelings about the sunglasses reminds me of a moment in "A Thousand Splendid Suns" in which one of the main characters expresses fondness towards her niqab as it allows her to observe others without them knowing or making judgements on her appearance. I often feel that my eyes give me away when I am intently observing my surroundings, and although I am dressed much less conservatively than a woman in a niqab, I enjoy feeling like my judgements are hidden.

Another aspect of this whole gender thing has been the inner conflict over my feelings. On the one hand, I came to Jordan to learn about the country, the culture, and the language. I don't think it is my place to make judgements on any of those things, and I think that being disapproving or judgmental will only hinder my experience here. At the same time, I am a proud feminist and big proponent of gender equality, and I am often very critical of people of all genders (myself included) in the United States when I witness gender discrimination. I know that there are Jordanian women who feel trapped by the societal expectations regarding their behavior, schedules, and clothing, and it has been interesting for me to hear about some of the ways they deal with that frustration.

A sign outside the entrance of my gym
that reads "Men are prohibited from
entering." Most gyms in Jordan are
segregated by gender, or have certain
times designated for men or women. 
I quickly decided to join an all women's gym, as I thought it might be a haven of sorts. In some ways it is; I can wear a tank top and shorts, no one stares at me (except for the occasional glance at my super red, post-workout face), and there is a hair dryer so that no one has to go outside with wet hair (I guess it is considered sexual, but I'm not sure how true that really is). However, the gym is also in a basement with no windows (so that the women don't have to cover their bodies or hair) and, I learned, not totally safe from men. Last week, in the middle of my workout, a women ran into the room with the treadmills and other machines and frantically explained that men had arrived to fix some of the machines. As she struggled to cover her hair with a scarf, she told us that we all needed to go wait in the bathroom (and stand far away from the glass door) for about 10 minutes until they finished. It ended up being more like 20 minutes, and I noticed that a few of the other women weren't happy, but it was all in a very resigned way.

I was pretty frustrated with the whole ordeal because I just wanted to finish my workout, and I didn't care if a man saw me in a tank top and shorts. I understood that I needed to respect the culture, but I think I was also upset because I didn't feel like I was making a choice to do that. Rather, the gym employees had ordered me to hide my body, and I resented the whole situation. I have still been going to the gym since then, and there haven't been any more interruptions from men, but I feel a bit that the haven bubble has been burst.

However, there is a happy ending to my post. Yesterday, much to my surprise, I ended up finding my feminist space in my Arabic class. We spent most of the day talking about violence against women, and despite the heaviness of the topic, it was a really enjoyable class. I felt empowered by the new vocabulary I learned that enabled me to discuss sexual assault, abortion, physical and verbal abuse, and the solutions to these issues. Probably the biggest challenge I've faced since coming to Jordan is not being able to express myself; given the fact that I have only studied Arabic for four semesters and I am expected to speak in Arabic at all times, it is understandable that I can't always say what I want to.

After yesterday's class, I know how to complain about the catcalling and staring I encounter everyday. I also got to hear my classmates express their frustrations with mistreatment of women, both in Jordan and the United States, and it made me feel closer to them. Finally, discussing these topics with my professor, my TAs, and CET's academic director (who was in the room at the time), all of whom are Jordanian women, made me feel like I can continue to find Jordanian women who are just as frustrated as me. Finding people to talk to and be in solidarity with gave me much more peace of mind than the women's gym did, and I feel like that feeling can't and won't be burst as easily.

4 comments:

  1. Belly button!
    This post is amazing :) Love your understanding and compromise in a socially complex culture. I think sometimes Middle eastern women think of it in the sense that their feminism and power comes from not showing skin and not letting men into their space. Have any women that you've talked to mentioned something like this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi!! Thank you for reading!!
      I definitely have encountered women who have that mindset, and I find it really interesting to talk with them and hear the complexities of it. I think it even might be helpful for me to try to adopt it, and I think that dressing conservatively has been the least difficult aspect of the transition for me, although I know some of the other girls in my program are very frustrated with it. What was your experience like in Turkey?

      Delete
  2. Bel, I also loved reading this blog. You speak to a tension that people around the world face when they voluntarily become a visitor in a society that is not theirs by birth: How can I, as a foreigner, learn to move through this society without always standing out? In some circumstances, that is easier to do. In this case, the tougher question seems to be: given this society’s expectations for how people like you/me (adult females) will dress, appear and behave in public, as well as our sense that these expectations are unfair, how can you understand and “respect” this culture, and find a way to live and move comfortably within it -- without feeling that you are either complicit in sustaining an oppressive system or simply “opting out” when you can?

    You have identified several things that are already helping you feel more comfortable: not just knowing places, customs, and how to get around, but also having friends, both fellow foreigners and fellow females, with whom you can talk, listen, and learn strategies -- strategies for protecting yourself, your space, your right to move through public space, and to do so safely.

    Wearing sunglasses is one such strategy, as they enable you to see what’s happening around you and to feel somewhat “protected” as you take in your surroundings and sometimes stare back at men who are staring at you. The parallel with the niqab is interesting, but I’m glad you don’t have to wear one just to be safe in public. Endeavoring to travel in groups is another tactic, although there will certainly be times when you just want or need to get somewhere on your own. It’s great that you are finding ways to talk with Jordanian women about how they manage and how they feel. I hope that you will continue to talk with and learn from the people you meet, to better understand their perspectives and their strategies for dealing with these expectations of women in public.

    Your blog raises many questions for me. How do expectations for women’s appearance and behavior change in situations where there are no men present? What about in mixed-gender family gatherings? When and where do women feel most free to be themselves? What expectations are there for the appearance and behavior of men in public -- and in private? Are men ever publicly shamed or made to feel unwelcome, especially if they are alone?

    You are absolutely right that when faced with complex cultural realities like these, it is “empowering” to learn words and to find and create spaces where you can discuss compelling issues, share your experiences and learn from others, and in this way, come to be “in solidarity” with others. I hope that as you interact with many people, you will continue to deepen your understanding of what is at stake in these and other social norms. I also hope you’ll continue to share your observations and discoveries through this blog. I know I’m not alone in loving to read what you write and thus being able to imagine you there. Sending you much love always, Belsi!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for always reading my blog posts and supporting me! I miss you a lot <3

      As for your questions, I will do my best to answer them.

      As my class is all female students and most of our TAs, as well as our professor, are women, I often spend a lot of time with just women in an academic context. I noticed certain changes between my professor's behavior when there are male students or TAs in the classroom and when there are not. It is very subtle, but she fidgets with her clothing more often when there are men there, probably to make sure everything is in the right place (her hijab often slips). She also showed us pictures from a party that she went to; it was only women in the room, and she was wearing a sparkly, knee-length, tank top dress. We, of course, all "ooh-ed" and "ahh-ed" because it was really pretty, but it was also interesting to see her dressed so differently than her school clothes. It also seemed to me that although she was a bit hesitant at first to show us (maybe because of "professional" reasons), she probably wouldn't have showed the pictures to male students.

      The other place that I've seen women behave and dress differently is in the gym. Most still wear leggings or pants, but there are often other women, too, who are in just sports bras or tank tops or shorts. Aside from the time that men showed up to fix the machines, it seems that most women in the gym feel very comfortable to move, dress, and say whatever they want. The gym is also the only place I've seen a picture of the Jordanian queen (Rania) without a picture of the king (Abdullah II).

      My understanding of mixed-gender family gatherings is that it depends on the family. If it is just immediate family, I don't think anyone really cares what is worn, but I think that if more distant relatives come over, in some families that means that women should cover up.

      I haven't seen many men wearing shorts, and most were foreigners, but it is more culturally acceptable for men to wear shorts that hit or cover their knees. I haven't really talked much with the male students or Jordanian men about any of these topics, mostly because I don't really feel comfortable doing that, but maybe that will change in the future.

      Delete