*This post may seem a little negative, and I apologize for that, but I try to be as honest as possible on my blog.*
Today I am having an existential crisis. I am very aware that I've grown up in a very privileged lifestyle. I have two parents who have their Ph.D.'s and both of them work full time jobs. I've always known that I would have access to both basic needs and luxuries, from having readily available, healthy food and a roof over my head to owning an iPhone and attending college. I think that financial privilege is the aspect of privilege that I find most overwhelming, but I also recognize that as a white, non-religious person living in the United States, I lead a very different life than many people in the world. These are things that I took for granted for most of my life until I slowly began to question these regularities. It was very difficult for me to acknowledge and accept my privilege while I was in Brazil because I mostly interacted with either very wealthy or very impoverished people. I saw many wealthy people, both Brazilian and not, who flaunted their money and had no self-awareness, while I witnessed many of the short- and longterm struggles of poorer people. I felt a variety of emotions, including guilt, shame, confusion, and despair, as I realized that there wasn't a whole lot that I could do about it. I still feel conflicted about the time I spent volunteering with Project Favela. While I went in with good intentions, I still haven't decided if the work that I did ultimately benefited or harmed the community.
When I was working at the hostel, I continued to struggle daily with this conflict about the ethics of my actions. I would take a bus to work that started in the North Zone of Rio, an area that is largely populated with favelas, and brought the waiters, supermarket cashiers, and maids to the rich neighborhood of Ipanema. I lived in another wealthy neighborhood and the stop that I got on at was the last one before people started getting off to go to their jobs. Every day I was met with hostile glares as I made everyone squish together even more to make room for me on the crowded bus, and I can't say that I blame them. Eventually I started biking to work with the excuse that it would give me a chance to get some more exercise in. I guiltily realized later on that I was really just avoiding the discomfort of being the rich, white girl taking up space on the bus.
I wish I could give some happy ending to this and say that these experiences made me a better person, but instead I feel the need to admit the truth: at the end of my time in Brazil, I was very, very excited to return to the United States where I knew that I could go back into my bubble of privilege in Champaign-Urbana. I wouldn't experience the glares from people on the bus and I wouldn't feel guilty about having my own bedroom and bathroom. I wouldn't think twice about spending a lot of money on jeans or dorm decorations. I would never question my safety as I walked around my neighborhood. I'm ashamed to say that I slipped right back into that life without a problem. A lot of people, especially ones who I had met while volunteering, asked me if it was difficult to transition back. I knew that it should have been, so I lied and said that it was, all the while pushing away the guilt that threatened to consume me. That guilt has been growing in the last 6 months and in the past few weeks it has really begun to boil over. I guess it makes sense that today I reached the breaking point while I was reading the chapter of my anthropology textbook called "Applications of Cultural Anthropology."
My anthropology textbook highlights a few issues that applied anthropologists can work with, such as food security, health and disease, environmental degradation, and military intelligence. It talks about the outbreak of viruses such as Ebola, which made me think of Zika, which broke out while I was in Brazil. It was a huge area of concern for many Brazilians, which made sense because a lot of the people who were being so negatively affected by the virus did not have access to clean drinking water, healthy food, and adequate health care. When I came back from Brazil, a lot of people asked me if I had been worried about getting Zika. My response was always no, because I knew that I had access to those things and that the likelihood of me suffering permanent damage or death if I caught it was very, very low. The inequality that is so pervasive in health care around the world is ridiculous, but I don't know how to fix that. The textbook also states that a billion people go hungry every day, a fact that contrasts so strongly with my own relationship with food. I have grown up in a society that makes jokes about starvation (i.e., "Finish the food on your plate because there are poor, starving children in Africa.") and wastes food without thinking twice. This morning, for example, I threw out a portion of my scrambled eggs because I was served more than I wanted to eat. I felt a little guilty about it, but no one in the dining hall questioned my actions, and why would they when there is so much food to spare there? The fact of the matter is that a lot of people have a huge surplus of food and even more people don't have enough, but nothing is being changed about that.
The more I read of my chapter, the worse I felt. I have spent the last 6 months, as well as most of the last 18 years, living a wasteful and ignorant life. I realize that is a very negative way to describe it, but I do feel that it is true. I am worried about the state that our world is in, environmentally, socially, financially, etc., and I feel like what I do everyday further hinders the situation. Don't get me wrong, I don't think that I am the only person who contributes negatively. The problem is that so many people are so accustomed to this lifestyle of comfort and privilege. I guess what the conflict that I am experiencing is what I should do about it. I know that there are a lot of other people who feel the same way as I do. I am comforted by the fact that there are people and organizations, both governmental and nongovernmental, that are trying to fix these problems, but I don't know how I can fit into that scene. I know that I am only 18 and don't know a whole lot about the world yet, so I can't expect to do much right now. I also take comfort in the fact that one day I will have more tools that can, hopefully, be used in combatting a lot of these issues, but I still am struggling with a lot of things. I can't fix this all by myself, and so even if other people and I end up devoting our lives to trying to distribute food more evenly around the world or some other humanitarian cause, what's to say that more people won't be sabotaging our efforts, either purposefully or not? And should I be doing more now? Is it bad for me to continue to use my iPhone every day and not eat all of the food on my plate? Should I not get excited when I buy new clothes or plan a movie night with my friends? I feel proud of myself for being aware of the things in the world that I see as problematic, but I am unsatisfied with the actions I'm taking...and yet, I don't know how to fix that without feeling guilty for my entire life. If you are reading this and have experienced similar conflict, I would love to hear about how you deal or have dealt with it.
love this post Issy. Its really hard, especially in the communities that we are from, to always be self aware and look at the bigger picture. Still, it helps to care about the world like you do and want it to be a better place. Youre never too young to start making a change and because you are so self aware its an amazing first step!
ReplyDelete